The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #52: Using Innovative Solutions to Contol Costs - With Christopher Fisher
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In today’s market, employers expect their benefit advisors to bring them new ideas to control costs. Our today’s guest, Christopher Fisher, Founder & President of BenefitsAlly, finds companies that are doing unique things that can take employers beyond the traditional method of increased employee responsibility.
We discuss the three hallmarks of “intelligent health care solutions”. Chris believes that advisors who use those ideas and come up with creative solutions are going to thrive, and those who continue on the same old path will soon fade away.
Our conversation also explores new ways that benefits advisors can leverage historical data and make strategic recommendations to reduce future costs. Since this is a new conversation for many advisors we talk about how to broach that discussion with employers and how to provide them with concrete solutions based on the analysis of that detailed, granular data.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Whether or not cost shifting is a dead strategy for dealing with employer spend.
- What “intelligent health care solutions” are.
- How billions in venture capital will change tools in our markets.
- The 3-step process for evaluating employers’ benefits.
- How we can transition from a rear-view mirror use of data.
- How to help employers use cost data at the employee level.
These days, controlling costs means much more than just increasing employee responsibility. But how can advisors find the patterns in their clients' data and use them to offer innovative solutions? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 prospecting solutions. Employee benefits, property and casualty, and financial professionals all rely on this affordable, easy-to-use, real-time search engine to find their target prospects in both large and small group markets. Visit www.myedge.biz for more information, or click on the sponsor link at shifthapersonline.com. Today on Shift Shapers, we're talking with Christopher Fisher. Christopher is founder and president of Benefits Ally, and he's one of the real thought leaders in our industry. And we thought it would be a great idea to kind of get his take on some of the future trends and some of the things that are going on in the industry. So with that, welcome, Christopher.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, David. I appreciate you having me.
DavidThank you for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. How did you get to we we're always interested on Shift Shapers in people's journey, you know, kind of where they started their professional career and how they ended up doing what they're doing now. What was your journey like?
SPEAKER_00So I have an interesting background. Two separate industries. I've spent some time in the uh technology sector working for a couple of very large technology firms, and also in the employee benefit space, working on the carrier and also on the brokerage side. And uh one of the things I started realizing is you know what, there are all of these cool companies and cool ideas out there from a cost control perspective, but that most benefit consultants have zero free time to stay on top of it. And it just became an idea in my head that I was fascinated about for a long, long time. And about three years ago, I started having the conversation with some brokers, and uh enough guys said, you know what, that's a really good idea. I think you should give this thing a shot. So I did, and three years later in 2015, here I stand.
DavidInteresting. You know, it's never a straight line, is it?
SPEAKER_00It never is. And even the last three years have not been a straight line. We're constantly evolving, but I think that's what makes this exciting. There's so much room for innovation and creative thinking in the employee benefits industry, especially today. And I think the guys who are truly creative and innovative are gonna thrive, and the guys who are content to do the status quo, same thing they've been doing, they're gonna disappear. That's exciting to me.
DavidNo question, and that's a great jumping off point for some of the substantive parts of our discussion. We talk about, you know, doing the same things or doing things that are innovative and forward-looking. In an earlier episode, we talked to our friends at ZyWave and they did a survey of employers. And even today, all these years past, post-ACA, with all the new ideas that are floating around, what they found wasn't surprising to a lot of us, and that's that today, most employers are still trying to use cost shifting as a way of managing their costs. Is that gonna be an effective strategy much longer?
SPEAKER_00I certainly wouldn't think so. I mean, I think as more and more companies cost shift, benefits get more and more expensive, I think you're starting to see people and employees opting out of the system in general. They're saying, look, deductibles are so high, it's crazy expensive, I'm gonna opt out, and people start looking at individual policies. And for benefit consultants that are in the group business, that's a serious, serious problem. I think the good news is for brokers and consultants that are innovative, there are hundreds, if not thousands, of companies out there doing creative things to control the cost of healthcare. It's just a matter of if you're a busy benefit consultant, how do you stay on top of that? You know, I was looking at an article recently and I forgot the number. Uh it was billions of dollars of venture capital funding going into companies doing creative things in the healthcare space right now. So there's no shortage of innovative ideas and things happening. It's just a matter of how do benefit consultants and brokers working with employers stay leverage that. Because talking about raising deductibles and HSAs and the same stuff everybody else is talking about, I think is uh is it's not a winning strategy.
DavidNow, and we've talked about it on the podcast before that, you know, interestingly enough, stuff that used to be a differentiator for a benefit advisor, today it's table stakes. If you don't have that stuff, you can't go talk to an employer. So you have to be able to bring new things to the table. They're expecting it. And I really think, you know, one of the things that this that survey pointed out was that employers are more and more looking to their advisors to try to bring them some new ideas. And you take a top-level view of those and you call them, you have a great phrase for them, you call them intelligent healthcare solutions. What does that mean? What is an intelligent healthcare solution?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question. And and uh intelligent healthcare solutions was kind of a tagline when I first started the company. But for us, I'm always looking for companies that I think meet three three criteria. One, it's intelligent. Is it a smart idea? Is it something that I think intuitively makes sense? Is in the healthcare space we're always looking for things that can control medical and pharmacy costs. Nobody's worried about life insurance rates or disability rates. They're worried about healthcare costs, medical and pharmacy. And then also, is it a solution? Does it solve a problem? You know, whether it's pharmacy costs, pharmacy costs are a big one actually right now. Healthcare transparency are trying to drive more participation in the HSA, they're trying to create a marketplace to let providers compete for their business. There are lots of problems out there. And are there solutions out there to solve those problems? And the short answer is there are a lot of really great solutions out there. And that's what uh that's what I'm looking for. And we spend hours and hours each week talking to companies that we think are doing unique things that uh you know can solve problems out there in the marketplace.
DavidYou mentioned pharmacy and let's let's kind of take a side road out there. What percentage of overall medical spend for an average company is pharma driving today?
SPEAKER_00You know, uh, that's a great question. It's really all over the map. A lot of it's probably demographic based more than anything else. If you've got a young oil and gas population, I'm in Texas, we've got a lot of oil and gas business, young, healthy guys, not a whole lot. You've got an older population, maybe an architecture bank, law firm, it's a lot higher. I honestly don't know the answer. I probably should, but it's it varies. I will tell you that pharmacy costs are growing a lot faster than medical costs. Almost every benefit consultant we talk to is constantly going, what can we do on the on the pharmacy side? Because it's a it's a hot button issue.
DavidWhen you talk to advisors, I know you kind of use a matrix of a three-step process. Can you take us through that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so we use a process called DOM. And again, I come from the technology side where acronyms are king. So DOM stands for data opportunity money. So when I sit down with a benefit consultant who's looking for some creative ideas, the first thing we always talk about is it's data. Data is king. When benefit consultants go out there and say, hey, here's this interesting idea, I want to talk to you about X. If I'm an employer, I'm inherently skeptical because you have no idea what's actually happening in my health plan. So the key thing for any benefit consultant to me is always starting with data. Unless you get detailed, detailed claims data. And I'm not talking about a nice, pretty PDF report that's premium versus claims. I'm talking granular data, NDC codes, CPT codes, plan paid, member paid, retail versus mail order, all that kind of stuff. Data is key. And then from that perspective, it's what you do with that data, um, really drilling down into that data and looking at all of those dozens of opportunities that are out there. You know, again, pharmacy solutions, telemedicine, healthcare transparency, bundled case rates, audit plays, trying to figure out what of those opportunities make sense based on the data. And the last part, M is just money, trying to understand what the financial impact of those solutions would be. So when a benefit consultant sits down with an employer and says, you know what, here's a particular, you were struggling with pharmacy costs. We reviewed every single penny of your pharmacy spend in the last 12 months, looked at the drug spend, generic versus brand, et cetera. And here are a couple of solutions, specific solutions that we think make sense for this group. And here's here's the money, here's the financial impact. When you have that conversation, it's far more credible as uh as a benefit consultant and as an employer than just going in and talking about the same stuff everybody else is talking about.
DavidNow a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. The MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution makes it fast and easy to find the qualified leads you need to grow your business. Who uses the MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution? Employee benefits brokers who need to find accurate eligible employee numbers and employer contact information. Property and casualty agents who need to know which employers are out of compliance with their fidelity bond, and if they need to increase their bond coverage. Financial professionals who need to identify plan types, asset size, high commissions, and fees. MyEdge enables you to search for employers with 120 benefit eligible employees or fewer. By geographic region, employer contribution, employee participation, industry segment, and more. Register for a free live webinar at www.myedge.biz to see how easy it is to find qualified small group leads. Or click the sponsor button on the ChipShapersOnline.com website. Data and the discussion of data and how you dig into it seems to be understandably a recurring topic on this program. And a question that I'll ask sometimes is this, and I'd love to get your take on this. In our industry, we do a great job in terms of data of looking out the rearview mirror to use an automobile analogy. The holy grail for us in terms of really being able to bend trends and manage costs is going to be trying to get to a point where we look out the windshield with kind of a heads-up display. How do we get there? Or is it not possible to get there?
SPEAKER_00You know, that's an excellent question. And it's it's not easy. From our perspective, I think we obviously take a historical view first. We want to look out the rear window and see what happened in the past. You know, history is obviously a great indicator of what's going to happen in the future. So for benefit consultants, if you look back and look at where things were spent in the past, I think you can make some more credible recommendations about what's going to happen in the future and then what your alternatives are if you take some strategic, some strategic action. There was a consultant recently who brought some really unique pharmacy solutions to an employer. And he said, look, you know, your costs are rising significantly, double digits year over year, and said, We want to try and bring some unique solutions to the table. So we they went out, crunched the pharmacy data, and brought a particular solution to the plot in play that could save that employer over $200,000, which equated 30%. Now, again, that's historical data, so it's not the forward-looking data I think we're all looking for. But the employer said, you know what? I appreciate the fact that you're out there trying to be creative and be forward thinking. So, you know, trying to protect my spend and my bottom line in 2015 and going forward. So I think for benefit consultants, I think the key is to leverage the data in the past and try and make strategic recommendations to reduce costs in the future. I think is certainly a huge opportunity for innovative brokers and consultants in 2015 and beyond.
DavidSo you don't see, as as we sit here today, you don't see us really being able to use a viable predictive modeling engine.
SPEAKER_00I think there are some out there, and it's interesting. I talked to some companies that are trying to do that, again, with all the venture capital flowing into healthcare. I think it's possible. I don't think we're necessarily there yet. And I think a lot of the challenge around a lot of this stuff, and this gets back to disease management and wellness and other things like that, which I am ambivalent on. I think it's really hard to say what the dollar value is of a prevented heart attack or whether you would even prevent a heart attack by doing certain things to begin with, right? If you help somebody lose 15 pounds or lower their cholesterol by 15 points, that's intuitively a good thing, but does it have a material impact on the bottom line that you can tie back to and track? And I'm ambivalent on that, frankly. To me, what's far more interesting is trying to reduce hard dollar costs for an employer. To me, it's way more compelling if you can walk into an employer and say, look, here's an option for a transparent marketplace, let's say, where we've repriced some claims and walked in, we can we think we could save you $800,000. And here's line by line about what you were paying in 2013, 2014, and what you could pay with this solution in 2015. That to me is way more credible to a CFO, to business owners who are increasingly engaged in these conversations versus kind of on the health improvement disease management side. Not that you can't do that, nor you know, or you shouldn't be doing that, but in the conversations we have, hard dollar stuff I think is way more compelling because they're looking to save money now.
DavidYeah, and you raise an interesting issue. And we talk again, a lot of us who who kind of look out into the future and gaze into our crystal balls and see kind of you know what we think is coming, talk a lot about transparency, both around quality and price. Where are we today on both of those parts of transparency? Where do you see it going? And how does it kind of a three-part question. Third part, how do today's advisors leverage that to bring better solutions to their employers?
SPEAKER_00That's an excellent question. So, you know, where are we today? I I think we're certainly better than we were than we were several years ago. There are certain states, Massachusetts, I think, just rolled out a mandatory transparency law. So there are a lot more transparency tools out there. The carriers provide some okay tools. There are some third-party companies who specialize in the healthcare transparency space. Some are better than others. I think the challenge twofold is number one, even though those tools are available, what does the engagement rate look like? If you can help somebody find out, an MRI might range from 500 to 3,000 based on where you go in a given market like Austin, where I reside. But the question is, how do you get the rank and file employees who are making the decision about where to get that MRI actually go? And there are some decent tools in that space. I really actually think we're gonna start seeing the death of networks actually longer term. I think this whole idea of having a you know network where you say, you know what, the build rate is X, and but because you're part of this network with a major carrier, you're gonna get 45, 50, 60, 70% off build charges, I think is really kind of a flawed premise. We're starting to see some traction or a lot of interest in employers and almost like a direct payer kind of a cash model, where you're saying providers are saying, what are the procedures we can do cost effectively at a certain price? And they they accept what almost looks and feels like cash to them, where they say, you know what, we know that we can do hip replacements or steroid ejections or MRIs at a certain price point, and we want to get out of the insurance game. So we're gonna take what equates to a cash price for these procedures. And it's fascinating because those cash prices can be very, very competitive, in fact, in some cases dramatically less than the network prices that exist today. You know, I I talk to employers and benefit consultants are starting to have this conversation where they'll say something along the lines of healthcare transparency tools are great. They'll tell you if you've got five providers in a given market that one is a 3,000, one is 2,000, one is 1,500, et cetera. They're gonna help you find the lower cost provider, the one that's let's say 1,000 versus 3,000. But if there are providers in your market that are willing to do it for like 350 or 400, kind of outside the typical insurance system, why aren't you going to those providers? You know, healthcare transparency to use an analogy from a friend of mine, they often will tell you kind of the best bad deal within a network. And even if it's a best bad deal, is it really a good deal to begin with? So I think actually we may start seeing the death of networks over time because I think it's kind of a flawed premise.
DavidAaron Powell Do you see those providers of bulk pricing being ACOs? Are ACOs going to kind of step into the into that placeholder in the system?
SPEAKER_00They certainly could. I think the ACOs have not stepped in there yet. I think they might. I don't necessarily think the idea of having one massive organization that tries to do everything, you know, be all things to all people, is tough. I think we actually might see even some more sub-specialties. You're saying, look, we're a hospital or we're a small provider group, and these are the 10 things we do. And we do these 10 things really, really well, high quality, low cost, but we're not going to try and be all things to all people. I think that whole idea of trying to do that is is tough. Um time will tell.
DavidWell, one of the things that we talk about when we look at claims and claims cost is setting. We're hearing starting to hear some rumblings in some markets about on-site and near site clinics. Are are you seeing that? And do you think that's a trend that's going to keep growing?
SPEAKER_00I do. I certainly think we're seeing more and more of it. I think it's going to trend that's going to continue, continue to grow. It's challenging because obviously we talk to employers all the time who are interested in it. The key question is whether they have the population to justify in a central enough location. Well, I talked to a benefit consultant recently who had a client, and they were really interested in the idea of it, but when push came to shove, they had roughly four or five hundred employees, and just the economics of it didn't make sense. I certainly think there's going to be more and more interest around on-site clinics. I think access to care is a huge deal. I think a lot of people have insurance, but can they actually get to see the doctor in on a timely basis? So I think it's going to be a bigger and bigger trend. I think the question is, can they make the economics of it work? One of the solutions we brought to a benefit consult that he liked for smaller mid-market employers was kind of an on-site, a hybrid on-site clinic, but the expensive part of an on-site clinic, kind of the build at cost, the on-site doctor, all those kinds of things were shared. So this is this is kind of a technology play where they they throw a tea cart in an existing, let's say, 10 by 10 room in an office staffed with a paramedic, and all of the equipments and the tools, the you know, stethoscope, all the other equipment has HD cameras and microphones in that feedback to a shared doctor. So this is an employer who could roll out a clinic for half to a third of the traditional cost because the expensive part, the build out on the doctor, was shared among multiple employers. So I think that may be something you start seeing more and more of in kind of the middle market space. But I certainly we're having more and more conversations about it and more and more employers are interested in it. And I think they should be.
DavidSo, Christopher, as we kind of wrap up here, how does the conversation with a benefit advisor go? I mean, what are those interactions that you're having like? And what are you hearing and how do you advise them?
SPEAKER_00You know, I talk to benefit consultants all the time. I was uh uh talking with a colleague. I've been in 16 cities in 2015 so far. So, you know, from West Coast, East Coast, Southeast. And I think benefit consultants, they're nervous about the future, and I think they should be. They're nervous about what kind of value can they continue to provide to exist, not just in 10 years, but five years. I think the benefit consultants that are thriving are the ones that are always open and looking for innovative solutions. They've always got kind of a you know set of eyes out there, combing the market, looking for creative ideas. Because their value going forward is not about showing up with a spreadsheet or talking about HSAs or cost shifting. To me, it's about bringing good ideas to justify those commissions and fees you're paying. Because if you can't justify those commissions and fees, you're in a lot of trouble. But the guys who are out there taking a hard look at data, bringing creative ideas to the table, if you can walk in and show an employer how to save $500,000 on medical and pharmacy costs, the conversation around your $75,000 annual consulting fee is a very easy conversation to have. You can say, look, we're charging you $500,000 or we're charging you $75,000, but I just save you $500,000 on your pharmacy costs. That's an easy conversation to have. The guys who are out there passing along rate increases and talking about the same stuff everybody else is talking about, they're gonna get killed. I think the good news is for the forward-thinking guys, the guys who are willing to kind of buck the status quo and be creative, there are dozens and dozens of cool ideas out there that we're talking to all the time. So I'm excited about the future of the industry. I think the brokers who are excited about the future of the industry, who are willing to be creative and innovative, are as well.
DavidGreat place to leave our conversation today. Christopher Fisher, founder and president of Benefits Ally. Christopher, thank you again for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, David. I really appreciate your time.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies, just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of ship shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the ship shapers to work in your business.