The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #51: Compliance and The Regulatory Maze of the Affordable Care Act with Arthur Tacchino
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
ACA and its blizzard of ever-changing regulations has created a challenging environment for even the most proficient advisors. We asked Arthur Tacchino, Chief Innovation Officer & Principal of Sync-Stream Solutions, to discuss those challenges and to examine some of the ways advisors can master and profit from providing their clients with expert and timely advice.
Arthur is a lawyer by education and also serves as an assistant professor of health insurance at The American College. His concentration has been highly focused on this area of practice and has made him one of the leading subject matter experts on this ever-changing area.
In addition to discussing the compliance process, we also learn about the three phases of the process at the client level: analysis and modeling; decision making and documentation, and implementation and monitoring. Don’t miss this informative discussion that will give you some insight on how to operate in today’s evolving marketplace and help you prepare yourself and your clients in case of an audit.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- How Arthur went from a J.D. to Health Insurance.
- The unique challenges ACA has created.
- Supporting client discussions.
- The three phases of compliance.
- The impact and imprint of ERISA in ACA.
ACA has added a ton of legislative and regulatory complexity. What do advisors need to know to handle the compliance and regulatory maze of the Affordable Care Act? And how can technology help? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 prospecting solutions. Employee benefits, property and casualty, and financial professionals all rely on this affordable, easy-to-use, real-time search engine to find their target prospects in both large and small group markets. Visit www.myedge.biz for more information, or click on the sponsor link at shiftshapersonline.com. We're excited to have a very special guest on the program today. We're speaking with Arthur Techino. Arthur is Chief Innovation Officer and Principal at SyncStream Solutions. He's also an assistant professor of health insurance at the American College and a lawyer by education. And that might seem to be a really good start-off point for today's discussion. But first, welcome Arthur.
SPEAKER_02Thanks. Thanks for having me today.
DavidA pleasure. How do we go from a JD into the entire weird universe of healthcare in 2015?
SPEAKER_02It's actually really all happened by chance. I was graduating law school, and the opportunity came to interview for a position at the American College, which is a great educational institution. And healthcare form had just passed, and they were looking for a young attorney who really could dive into the law, create course content, and uh just tackle it. And I guess I had said the right things in our interview to prove that I was that person, and then they gave me a chance, which I've been very grateful for, and um really went to the college, created the course content, developed a couple courses there that are now taught in their curriculum, did that for several years. And while doing that, we were educating agents, brokers, attorneys, CPAs all over the country on the law, and um from there really decided that there needed to be some sort of practical solution out there to help advisors tackle the Affordable Care Act. It's extremely complex law, and it's reform across the board, which also makes it very unique. It's such a massive law that there really needs to be assistance in some way.
DavidWell, you know, when you said that you you when you were working with the American College, you got an opportunity to dive in. I mean, there's no question that ACA's created a real deep end of the swimming pool. So when you dive, it's a deep dive, and that's created some unique challenges for advisors as well, hasn't it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think the the law has really shifted the landscape for healthcare. I mean, it's really what advisors were doing prior to healthcare form has totally changed to what they need to be doing with their clients now. And I think that process has evolved over the past several years, and I think it's just gonna continue to evolve. Before, I think agents and brokers were more viewed as a salesperson as opposed to an advisor or consultant. And I think they're really shifting into a consultant's role. The law is just too complex. They're gonna be responsible to answer complex questions and advise their customers and clients on where they need to go in order to not only just comply with the law. I mean, I think that's the very bare minimum that they're gonna need to be able to do, but also to help navigate it in a manageable way moving forward. And that's gonna require a lot of knowledge for anybody who's operating in this industry, and also just continuing to keep up with everything because I think what we've everyone can agree on is that this law is constantly shifting or evolving and it and uh reshaping what people need to be doing, basically.
DavidWell, and your point's very well taken. I mean, we we've got, as you know, in this industry, a lot of sole practitioners, a lot of small practices scattered all over. It it really, this law has both the law and the the ongoing regulatory burden has really become an awful lot for a small practitioner to swim through. I was chatting with somebody the other day, and they they made a statement I found interesting. I wonder how you feel about it, that there are parts of this law and the regulations that have uh uh a fairly decent amount of ERISA DNA floating through it. Have you found that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I think in many instances the law actually refers to ERISA and says, you know, basically they're they're mirroring a lot of the requirements of ERISA and altering ERISA itself as well as all the other laws that are sort of entangled with this. I mean, I think that's very accurate and it also just creates a new level of complexity because ERISA is very complex, very detail-oriented, and and now you know they really weren't dealing with as many complex situations as they are right now.
DavidWell, and the reason I mentioned ERISA is because I think there's a common and comfortably held belief among a lot of advisors that if you get involved on ERISA plans, which to date has been kind of for most advisors, I would guess, mostly in the self-funded arena, that it's it's very common to have other systems, other practitioners, other specialties, whether it's attorneys or accountants or whatever, advising the plan. That's starting to be the case in terms of bringing in other advisors on other tool sets for advisors working with ACA, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's absolutely true. And I think, you know, this is something that we struggle with as we're trying to adapt to the environment we're in right now. Just look at the IRS reporting requirements, section 6055 and 6056. A lot of what employers are doing is they're, you know, they're obviously tracking the employees' hours of service and making that determination are they full-time. But when you look at what actually gets reported to the IRS, that information has to do with the offers of coverage that are being made. And so what you're seeing is employers and their advisors who are supporting all of this have to go to different systems to capture this information. They're pulling information from a payroll system, now they're pulling information from a benefits admin system, possibly a carrier, or some of this information has to be captured for the first time. And because they're dealing with so many different systems and so many different operations, they really do need a team of people to be really keeping track of all this information and advising the customer or client on what's going on, basically.
DavidWell, and I think, you know, when a lot of this started, most practitioners were focused largely on the pay or play question. But it's moved well beyond that, hasn't it?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. And I think, you know, you saw the market flooded with these player-pay calculators, you know, things that were very simple by nature, and then some things more complex. But that was just the initial jumping off point, I think. You know, are employers going to offer coverage or are they not? I think largely what we've seen is, yeah, employers are gonna continue to offer coverage. Now the question is, what type of coverage are they gonna be offering? What different schemes or systems are they gonna put in place to manage that? Are they changing their contribution levels? Are they adjusting the types of coverage, the tiers of coverage? And obviously, all of that's going to affect the reporting as well. So I think this is just an ongoing analysis, and the player-pay question was really just the jumping off platform.
DavidWell, and that that's a great place to spend a little bit of time talking about something that you've written extensively about, which is about process. And I know that your feeling is that compliance in all of the pieces that folks need to go through, advisors need to go through with their clients, is actually a three-step process. I thought, let's take a moment and analyze those those three steps. The first thing that you'd say that advisors need to worry about is analysis and modeling. Can you talk a little bit about that? Explain what both of those components are.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think first when you're sitting down with your client, you really need to determine how are they being affected by the Affordable Care Act. And that's where the analysis comes into effect. Are they an applicable large employer who's subject to the tax and the requirements and the reporting element as well? Based on sort of that determination or analysis, what are the different models that they could follow? You know, are they gonna drop coverage altogether? Are they going to continue to offer coverage? What plans are they offering? And once you sort of figure that out and lay out for the client what the options are, they then need to make that determination where they're going to go, which leads into step two of the process, which is really decision making and documentation. Now that I've laid out for my client all the options that are available to explain the potential consequences they could face by following those models, what are they going to do? And once they've made that decision, documentation is so key. I think we look at the IRS reporting, and uh the IRS is obviously going to be auditing employers as these reports start coming in. So I think having a compliance plan and documenting whatever that is and continuing that documentation is going to be very key for employers to maintain compliance. And then implementation and monitoring is really the third step. Implementing whatever your plan is, keeping track of that and making sure that you're maintaining compliance moving forward. It's one thing to get a documentation list and put it in a folder somewhere and say, I have that just in case we're audited. It's another thing to make sure that you continue to monitor what you're doing and make sure that it makes sense for you. Because you might go through that first cycle of a measurement, admin, and stability period and think the plan that you had in place was going to work successfully. But when you reevaluate it and you actually look at the outcome, you might need to shift and uh readjust to the landscape.
DavidYou use the A-word, so I'll follow up. You mentioned audits, and as somebody who spent better part of seven, eight years running a TPA, the thought of DOL audits still gives me the heebie jeebies. Do you anticipate that down the road that there will be audits? And I think maybe more to the audience's point, do you expect that there's within those audits that there's some advisor exposure?
SPEAKER_02I do think that down the road you're going to see audits. I think the government and even written into the law is the uh sort of a good faith effort standard, which basically I think what the IRS is trying to tell us is we know this is complex. As long as you're making a good faith effort to comply, we're not going to take it to the next level and sort of start full-blown audits. I think they're trying to give somewhat of a good faith effort grace period to employers in this first couple years of implementation. But after that, just like any law, the employer has to comply and has to be prepared for audits. And I think, yeah, I think brokers definitely have exposure there because I think it's just nature for an employer to say, hey, we're being audited. We were just doing what this guy told us to. So they're always going to be turning to the advisor to say, hey, you know, you told us to do this. Why are we in trouble now? Or why are we being audited? So I think advisors need to prepare their clients for that. Um, they need to prepare themselves for that as well. I do think that the first year of this implementation, the audit process will be much lighter, less strenuous because of that sort of good faith effort caveat that they've built in. I mean, obviously the IRS can't say all that, but I think that's what they're trying to imply with what they have said and what they've written about the law.
DavidNo, I mean, we saw that with Cobra and HIPAA and other regulations, laws and regulations that have come down the pike. So I think that's probably a great assessment of where that is. In terms of advisor exposure, does it make more sense for an advisor, especially as a small advisor or a solo practitioner, does it make more sense for them to try to outsource that? Or do you think that there are some shops that are going to be capable of doing that themselves?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's almost as an advisor, it's almost a case-by-case analysis. I think they have to be able to look themselves in the mirror and make that determination. I mean, we work with advisors all over the country and we see different levels of sophistication. They need to make the determination and then plan accordingly. So it's it's a self-analysis that needs to happen. Do you think you can take on that responsibility? If you're a sophisticated broker or advisor who, you know, this is your sole purpose and sole practice and this is what you're doing, then yeah, maybe you can answer those questions and take on that liability. But if you're not sure you can, don't do it. You would look to someone else, create business relationships. They're out there. Those possibilities exist all over. Turn it over to someone who has the level of sophistication, but don't be afraid to do that. Ultimately, it's going to serve you and your clients better.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. Want to find prospects in your area without cold calling, but with a warm introduction from a network relationship or from the prospect's accounting firm? How about finding companies that are out of compliance on their Form 5500 filing? What if you could find prospects that are paying more than standard compensation for their products and services? It can be difficult to find dependable business intelligence for both large and small group markets. With MyEdge, you'll have the ultimate unfair advantage. MyEdge makes it easy to create a pipeline of only qualified leads. You'll set yourself apart from the crowd when you know how to build a targeted value add strategy for the companies you want to work with. Clients and prospects always appreciate when their benefits consultants take the time to understand their employee benefits before they meet. Don't act and sound like everyone else. Learn more about this innovative prospecting solution by visiting www.myedge.biz or by clicking the sponsor link at shiftchapersonline.com. Let's shift a little bit to kind of a micro world that's been created that nobody talks about a lot in terms of these compliance and regulatory issues. But there have been a number of advisors, and there's an awful lot of conversation around, especially, you know, modest size employers moving from a group to an individual mode. How do advisors need to support those clients? Is it the same as supporting a mid-size or a larger group client?
SPEAKER_02No, I think, I mean, I think it's it's very different, but I think it's something that we are seeing, and I think advisors need to be prepared for that to happen. I think with the subsidies, and obviously, I don't know if we will talk about King v. Burwell for a moment or two, but I think depending on what happens with the subsidies, I think as long as they exist, a trend of shifting to this individual marketplace sort of model is going to continue. I think employers don't want to be seen as just, oh, we're dropping healthcare coverage, for example, and letting employees spend for themselves. But I think if you have low-wage individuals who work for you, it can benefit them to get them to a marketplace where subsidies are available and it can benefit the employer. And I think the messaging around that has to be very clear. And that messaging can be provided by an advisor. You have to be able to explain it as this is a win-win situation for both the employee and the advisor. And obviously the advisor is going to need to know how to operate in that marketplace as well as continue to manage the group issues that they're dealing with if the employer continues to go that route. That trend, I think, is going to continue. And I think advisors just really need to be prepared for it.
DavidOne of the things that those of us who've practiced for a long time have come to realize is that it isn't so much the law that becomes problematic. It's the regulatory changes in the regulatory environment where there's a lot of turmoil. And especially with this piece of legislation, so much of it seems to be kind of written in pencil on post-it notes. Do you expect that this sea of ongoing regulatory changes and directives is going to abate anytime soon, or do you think that we're going to continue to kind of have this ongoing avalanche?
SPEAKER_02That's a good question. I mean, I think the reality is it's going to continue. There are still some key provisions out there that we don't have detailed regulations on. I think if you look at the Cadillac plan tax or, you know, officially the excise tax on high-cost healthcare plans, that's still out there for 2018. And we haven't, I think recently, just a couple weeks ago, some proposed regulations came out from the Treasury. And I think just like all the other regulations we're going to see, they're going to continue to evolve. And I think what that is, it's the government reacting to the market. I think it's perceived that the government is placing all these regulations on employers and they're putting them in this tough position. I think the reality is if you talk to anyone who's writing those regs, they want to try to adjust the regulations to make it easier for everyone to comply. And they're trying to feel what's happening in the market when they release regulations. They get their notice and comments back. And it's not a perfect fit by any means. But I think what they're trying to do is adjust the regulations so that it becomes practical for employers and everyone else out there to comply. And I think because of that, the regulations are going to continue to evolve and shift because we don't know how the market's going to respond to the next set of regulations that comes out.
DavidWe usually, in the couple of minutes we have left, wrap up our interviews by talking kind of nebulously about what each one of our guests thinks about the future. But perhaps the thing to talk about for us in the nearest term future, and you raised the issue a little while ago, is King v. Burwell. So if it's decided in favor of the defendants, nothing changes. But if it's decided in favor of the plaintiffs, a lot can change. What's your take on where this is going? I won't ask you to prognosticate so much about what the court may or may not do, but if they do find in favor of the plaintiffs, what do you think is going to happen? And how do advisors react to that near-term and longer term?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think it's very complicated. And, you know, we've seen so many challenges to the law so far, and none of them have really put a dent in the law. I mean, besides the challenge to the individual mandate, which obviously affected Medicaid most of all, the Medicaid expansion, the law really has been only changed by the people writing the regulations. So I think from an advisor's perspective, what would happen is essentially if the state is not running the exchange, which only 13 states at this point are responsible for their own exchange, subsidies would go away. And I think what you're seeing is states are putting in place plans that if that's going to happen, they will adopt their own legislation to overtake the exchange and run it themselves so that the subsidies will come back. I don't think any politician out there wants to take away subsidies at this point from millions and millions of Americans. So I think it's definitely a fluid situation if the court does rule that way. But I think what what they need to be doing is looking to their own state legislature, seeing if there's a plan being put in place for that outcome and continuing to monitor that. It's certainly a fluid situation. I think ultimately advisors need to be tracking that and also what's happening in their state. Is there a backup plan for that outcome? And to basically try to position themselves based on that.
DavidWell, it certainly belies that old terse, may you live in interesting times, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
DavidArthur Tecino, Chief Innovation Officer and Principal at Synxtream Solutions. Arthur, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience today. Thank you for having me. The Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Shift Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the ship shapers to work in your business.