The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #50: Is Reference Based Pricing The Future of Sustainable Health Plans? - With Ryan Day
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Healthcare costs are rising and as we discussed in episode 48, most employers are still using cost shifting as a hedge. Ryan Day, our guest in this episode, believes that a better – and more sustainable – solution is Reference Based Pricing (RBP). We discuss the growing interest in reference based pricing and how it can put a serious dent in health care costs in the post-ACA environment.
Ryan is the President of H.S. Technology, and a subject matter expert in reference based pricing. We begin with the basics and then explore how this methodology fits in with today’s plans, who it is for, and how advisors can discuss it with clients.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- The problem with traditional pricing.
- What RBP is.
- Whether all constituencies need to collaborate to make RBP work.
- Whether RBP is currently a carrier or self-funded tool.
- The challenges of RBP.
- The impact of CMS’ data release.
While most employers are still mitigating costs using employee cost shifting, there's growing interest in something called reference-based pricing. What is reference-based pricing and can it really help rein in healthcare costs? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Stoltzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. Employee benefits, property and casualty, and financial professionals all rely on this affordable, easy-to-use, real-time search engine to find their target prospects in both large and small group markets. Visit www.myedge.biz for more information, or click on the sponsor link at shiftshapersonline.com. We're all accustomed to looking at prices on medical procedures and plans and whatnot as professionals. We delve into that all the time. And we've been in a period for the last four and a half or five years where costs have kind of mitigated. And today's program is not about the reasons for that. It's really more about the fact that there's a new study out, a couple of things that we've seen recently in the trade press that talk about health care costs rising. And what's interesting about that in today's context is that most employers are still using cost shifting techniques to ameliorate some of those rate increases. But some are beginning to embrace a new kind of a thing called reference-based pricing. Now you may not have heard a lot about it, but it looks like it has the potential to make a serious dent in costs. And so we invited Ryan Day. Ryan is president of HS Technology, and he's a subject matter expert in reference-based pricing, which we're going to refer to as RBP for the remainder of the call. So with that, welcome, Ryan.
SPEAKER_02David, I appreciate you having me.
DavidWell, thanks for sharing your expertise with the audience. We appreciate you being here. Absolutely. So we'll start with a really kind of a broad question. What's the problem with traditional pricing?
SPEAKER_02I think the problem in today's market is folks just trying to understand what they're getting a discount off of. Because when we we look at the typical health insurance carriers, they have some of the largest discounts on claims. But the problem is cost only goes in one direction. So if you're getting 50 to 60 to 70% discounts, our question is, well, what's it off of? We want to understand what other folks are paying for those services. And hence that's what reference-based pricing relates to.
DavidSo for the folks who are new to the concept, what is RBP?
SPEAKER_02So RBP is a reimbursement that uses both Medicare and cost to determine the prevailing price for all medical services. So we want to understand what Medicare pays for a certain service, but we also want to understand what the cost for the hospital is as well. Because you know, having a collaborative approach or reference-based pricing is definitely key.
DavidWhen you say collaborative, who are the collaborators?
SPEAKER_02Collaborators would be the employer groups, ourselves, and the consultants as well. Usually you want to be able to set a reference-based pricing plan at a certain a lot of folks will do a cost plus type model, others will do a Medicare plus type model. Depending on where you set that benchmark, can make your approach either less collaborative or very collaborative with the facilities.
DavidWell, so let's take it out of the academic, and maybe you can give us a case study or an example of how this might work to illustrate what you're talking about.
SPEAKER_02Sure, absolutely. So for instance, say I have a uh $20,000 claim from a surgery center. What happens? The claim will come in and we'll say, okay, let's take a look at what Medicare would have paid for this same type of procedure. And then let's go look and see what the cost of this procedure would have been. And we take both of those into account because having a collaborative approach, like you said, you want to always make sure that the facility is making more than their cost. And one thing you would do there when you're looking at a $20,000 claim and running it through the data sets, then all of a sudden you say, okay, well, I see that Medicare is paying $200 for that procedure. So if a plan is set up to reimburse, say, a Medicare plus model, so we'll say Medicare plus 50%, well, then if we're looking at a reimbursement of possibly $250 for that claim. So that's kind of a rudimentary example on how reference-based pricing works and is applied to all claims uh going forward.
DavidSo at the present time, I know we're we'll talk a little bit later about the future and where you see this going, but at the present time, is this mostly a tool in a to be used in a self-funded or carrier environment?
SPEAKER_02This tool would definitely be something that's used in the self-funded environment. We see that's where a lot of the folks are trying to understand their risk and understand their cost because as you stated earlier, there's only so much cost shifting you can put onto the member or the plan itself. Uh so I would say the majority of our clients that we see are all self-funded.
DavidAre you seeing more interest in this post-ACA than you saw before ACA?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I think with lifetime maximums going away, the amount of exposure that is out there is uh astronomical in the sense that it's no longer million-dollar claims. Now you can see claims as high as eight to ten million dollars. So there's a lot of exposure for folks out there, and they're starting to look to alternatives because there's only so much they can sustain for their plans. And these alternatives have really come about with ACA.
DavidOther than whacking hospitals on certain Medicare claims, ACA didn't do an awful lot relative to cost. Some might argue that it didn't do much of anything at all relative to cost. Is this an ACA compliant solution?
SPEAKER_02It is an ACA compliant solution. And I the nice thing about it is you're not limiting where people can go to certain facilities. You kind of turn the shackles off and cut it loose and say, you can go wherever you like, and then you let them know here are the facilities that do accept it, here are the facilities that don't. Doesn't mean you can't go to the facilities that don't, but there may be that potential where they they want to balance, build a patient or things like that. So you're not limited in those sense.
DavidThat's nice. So it might be an answer, at least in some measure, to skinny networks. Correct. How do you engage employees? We'll kind of bounce around a little bit here, but how do you explain this kind of a you can go anywhere you want but approach to an employee population?
SPEAKER_02So there's a few different things you can do with an employee population. And I will tell you with reference-based pricing, communication is key with the employees so that they understand what is exactly happening. And I can tell you by what we've done in implementations, when you educate the employees and they start to understand the cost and things like, well, if their grandparent had walked in and that's the price they pay, but since you know they're not of that age, they pay this price, it starts to really open up the eyes and educate the members. So it's been very, very well received when you do it uh heavy education up front.
DavidAnd presumably, like most of the things, consumer related, it requires, for our listeners to understand, it really requires, I would suspect, a buy-in by top management as well.
SPEAKER_02Correct. Absolutely. Top management, you know, being the CEOs, CFOs, HR folks, definitely the buy-in up there is definitely crucial.
DavidYou touched on this in an earlier answer. I'm interested. Are you seeing challenges from physicians and providers, or is this just taken kind of as an extension of the normal course of self-funded plans negotiating prices?
SPEAKER_02You know, it would all it really will all depend on the market setting and where you're at. So if you're in Texas, you know, a lot of facilities are more friendly in that area. So are physicians. But every facility is different, you know, when dealing with certain instances of reference-based pricing. I think for the most part, I mean, I'll just kind of throw some facts out there, but we see about 98% acceptance on our RBP plans. Uh, you will have providers that do want to understand what the reimbursement is. Usually on the physician side, PPO network is kept in place just for the physician only, just because of the fact we see most physician claims right around Medicare, pinging up as high as to 130% of Medicare. So not a lot of dollars there, but there can be. So usually that's where the majority of people they'll utilize their doctors and physicians more frequently than they would a hospital. So that definitely helps with reference-based pricing as well.
DavidBut in terms of like Willie Sutton, when when they asked him why you rob banks, so that's where the money was, in terms of really making a dent in cost, you're really looking at facility claims?
SPEAKER_02Correct. Absolutely. So we're looking at surgery centers, dialysis, inpatient, outpatient, psych centers. That's where a lot of the uh big dollars are taking place.
DavidHas there been any instance? Have you seen instances and what's happened where providers or facilities have tried to balance bill patients for whatever the difference between what they billed at and what ended up being negotiated?
SPEAKER_02Sure. We do receive uh instances where that does happen. Absolutely. And, you know, with reference-based pricing, something that's key to have in place is a patient advocacy center that can handle all of that uh to be able to talk with the facilities, pull the member out of the middle uh so that this doesn't take place. Uh, because you know it is a it can be an experience for the patient where it is, it's a little scary for them. They're not in this industry like we are, they're understanding everything and what's in place. So having somebody there to, you know, walk them through it and you know represent them on their behalf is definitely crucial when dealing with that.
DavidNow a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. The MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution makes it fast and easy to find the qualified leads you need to grow your business. Who uses the MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution? Employee benefits brokers who need to find accurate eligible employee numbers and employer contact information. Property and casualty agents who need to know which employers are out of compliance with their fidelity bond, and if they need to increase their bond coverage, financial professionals who need to identify plan types, asset size, high commissions, and fees. MyEdge enables you to search for employers with 120 benefit eligible employees or fewer. By geographic region, employer contribution, employee participation industry segment, and more. Register for a free live webinar at www.myedge.biz to see how easy it is to find qualified small group leads. Or click the sponsor button on the ChipShapersOnline.com website. Back a number of years ago, CMS finally started releasing claims data. How has that helped?
SPEAKER_02It's helped in a number of ways because before it was, you know, you're out there just in a black box not knowing the price. And this is the only industry left where the price is the price, you don't have no idea what the price is until after the services are done. If we were to, you know, operate that same way with mortgages, you know, go just sign on the dotted line, we'll tell you what your interest rate's going to be. And two weeks later, now you've got an interest rate of 35%. A lot of people don't operate that way. So this is the only industry where that still operates. So by releasing that pricing information has allowed us to put a lot of pressure, not only on the facilities. And, you know, believe it or not, we do have a lot of facilities that are our clients that do do this, but it's allowed us to be able to redirect care as well to facilities that are friendly to this and understand and get it and want to be a good community partner, a citizen.
DavidIs it still mostly uh a retrospective kind of a process as opposed to a prospective process?
SPEAKER_02You know, it depends on who you talk to in the industry. I know there are folks like myself, we do try to get ahead of it on elective surgeries, emergency surgeries, there's only so much you can do. But yes, you would be correct looking at the retrospective side. But we are, we take more of a proactive stance to try to get ahead as best as we can.
DavidDo you see that industry wide, or is that something that's that's changing? I know years ago when I ran a TPA, and even today with some of my consulting clients, we tend to look at stuff retrospectively. But I've heard, and you might be able to shed some light on this, that there is a move to try to do more prospectively.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. There's definitely a move to kind of get ahead of it. I know we work with several folks that that's what they try to do is try to spot and identify which folks are going to be those catastrophic cases and get ahead of this so it doesn't turn into a heart attack. And now they're just on their medications and the regiments and things like that. So there is a lot of folks out there that, you know, we do partner with that are helping us get ahead of that. But then even then on elective procedures, now having people call in to, you know, say, you know, what's the plan going to pay for this procedure if I go to this facility? We're really starting to see a movement there. So now folks start to understand the price before the services are rendered.
DavidAnd that's what we call consumerism.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. We're right there with you on that one. And I think uh consumer apps will definitely play a big role, especially with the generation that's up and coming, where they're always on their phones and you know they want a price and gratification right now. It'll be definitely crucial to be able to get information in their hands.
DavidWell, and I would also imagine that ACA, one of the lovely unintended consequences of ACA is that it's created a whole lot more individual consumers than we've had in a long time. And also, you know, we're we're dealing with folks who are now looking at significant personal responsibility on the metal plans. I suspect, I tell me if you agree or disagree that that that is going to get a lot of people interested in cost comparison and quality comparison up front.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I would completely agree with you. Now that there's more out-of-pocket risk for these members, they're gonna start to shop around to say, okay, who's gonna give me the best price? Problem being, where's you gonna where are you gonna get that price? And I'll give you an example is my father happens to be a CalPERS member. And you know, that model they went to was reference-based pricing, where they were gonna pay X amount for knees and hips. Here were the facilities that are gonna take it. Well, he received that letter in the mail letting him know here's what we're gonna pay, here are the facilities, accept it. Now you can still go to other facilities, but be advised that this is what we're gonna pay and you're on the hook. So now he's making that decision to say, okay, I'm not gonna go there, but I'm gonna go here instead. So you're absolutely right. I definitely see it moving in that direction.
DavidNow, we've got a whole baby boomer generation that's aging out and dealing with multiple chronic conditions. Is this a tool that's applicable to them as well?
SPEAKER_02It definitely is a tool that can be applicable to them as well. You know, especially if you know someone's wanting to shop for their healthcare, things like that. This tool can definitely be something that is a value when trying to understand the cost or where to go. Because, you know, believe it or not, some of the largest expense in a consumer's lifetime, you know, one is going to be their house, but two is going to be medical expenses, believe it or not. So it's we do all this comparison and price shopping when we're looking at furniture or houses or things like that. But then when it comes to medical, it's like, well, the highest price is the best price. And as we found, there is no correlation to high price and quality whatsoever.
DavidInteresting. Now, we've talked an awful lot about applying this to medical cost. Does it have an application to pharma as well? Because pharma's driving so much of the medical spend these days.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So, you know, that's another area that, you know, you're trying to peel back that onion because there's so many different layers in the pharma area. I know for ourselves in particular, we do work with a lot of folks that that's their expertise and doing the same thing we do on the medical side, they're doing on the pharma side to bring transparency. But it's definitely interesting because of the, I would say the lobbying forces that are in Washington, D.C. around the pharmaceutical are very prevalent in those instances.
DavidThey were prevalent in the run-up to ACA as well. Interesting looking at the new budget, at the president's new budget. They may be having second thoughts or a little bit of buyer's regret, I guess. But so maybe they'll come around a little bit more too. You mentioned your dad's experience with CalPers. I was interested to learn that one of the other early adopters was the Service Employees International Union.
SPEAKER_02Yes, SCIU. So in California, we are a referendum state. So they just need to collect a bunch of signatures. I think it was like 500,000 signatures, and then all of a sudden it's on the ballot, and all Californians are voting for this. So what they decided to do is I think they have about 100,000 members. What they decided to do is they were going to reimburse facilities at cost plus 25%. That's it. When they announced that they were going to do that, obviously the California Hospital Association and some of the other associations were not too happy or thrilled with this, including the networks as well, just because that kind of takes away their purchasing power of their discounts. So what ended up happening in that situation was SCIU ended up getting a closed door deal that, you know, wasn't disclosed, you know, to the rest of the public. But they understood this right up front that if we're going to be able to survive and continue, we can't keep going down this road. So that's when they said, you know, we're going to reimburse facilities cost plus 25%. So it was very interesting to see how that all played out.
DavidYeah, for folks who haven't ever worked with Taft Hartley plans, we we think of these unions as being these huge entities awash with money, but they're very, very careful on their medical spend. And I spent seven years administering plans for a variety of unions, mostly skilled trades, not the SEIU type of entities. And they're very careful, and they're very, you're right, they're very shrewd about how they spend their money.
SPEAKER_02And I would uh kind of add to that, some of the early adopters for reference-based pricing that we've seen around the market is Taft Hartley. They are growing in large numbers because they understand their risk and you know the things that they've promised to be able to have that sustainability, that's what they're looking at. So they are one of the fastest adopters of uh reference-based pricing.
DavidDo you see a move to marry the work in RBP with quality data as well? So that when a consumer is looking at a, let's use the term, a dashboard for lack of a better word, or doing research, they can look at both of those things and see the correlations?
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Those two go hand in hand. And I think, you know, for people to wrap their brains around reference-based pricing is the first step, uh, but the next step in the next generation is going to be value-based payments or value-based purchasing, where you're marrying the quality and the price to see who is exactly who you want to go to when it relates to a certain service. You know, do they have a lot of experience in doing that procedure? When they've done that procedure, have they had a lot of readmits, that type of thing? How good are they at doing that procedure? So, yes, absolutely. That'll that's gonna come into play here shortly.
DavidRyan, in the couple of minutes that we have left, I'm I'm always interested in what all of our guests think the future might look like, both relatively near term and then as far out as you know you think you can get. And these days, that may be just three years. But what's your vision of where this whole initiative goes in in the near term and in the midterm?
SPEAKER_02I know in the near term, there was a study released by uh Aeon Hewitt, and they had what they had done is interviewed a bunch of employer groups and were they going to take a look at reference-based pricing or implement it. And I believe it was uh right around uh 50% or 60% were looking to adopt reference-based pricing in some way, shape, or form within the next three years. So we see this movement definitely picking up steam. We already see the carriers starting to let certain procedures be done where it is reference-based pricing, but their definition of reference-based pricing is a little different. But we definitely see this being if you want a sustainable health plan, then reference-based pricing, I think, is definitely going to be the key to the answer for that. And that's kind of what we're seeing on the numbers as well, you know, with reference-based pricing plans kind of tracking right along with uh where Medicare tracks at about 1% a year. So definitely of significant value to a lot of folks when you start to look over, you know, multiple years and you start compounding that.
DavidBrave New World, Ryan Day, president of HS Technology. Ryan, thanks for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_02David, we appreciate you having us all the best.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of shift papers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the shift papers to work in your business.