The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #49: The Intersection of Property & Casualty and Employee Benefits with Frank Pennachio
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today, we discuss the crossover between the often separate worlds of property and casualty and employee benefits. Our guest Frank Pennachio is partner & co-founder of Oceanus Partners. Frank believes that the overlap in these two areas provides some challenges for employers and opportunities for advisors who can bridge the gap.
In this wide-ranging discussion, we begin by exploring workers compand they key for advisors to understand how to maintain eligibility during a claim. We also cover other federal laws such as FMLA, and how advisors can help to identify significant and completely avoidable risk to clients.
We also talk about the new discoveries in neuroscience and how they relate to the ability of advisors to create new sales channels and the strategies to fully profit from them.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- The crossover areas between property & casualty and employee benefits.
- Significant and avoidable risks and threats faced by employers
- The role of neuroscience in sales.
- New disruptive sales channels.
- Why ACA is not the driver of change.
Are property and casualty and employee benefits two distinct practice areas? Or are clients better served when those disciplines meet in the middle? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 prospecting solutions. Employee benefits, property and casualty, and financial professionals all rely on this affordable, easy-to-use, real-time search engine to find their target prospects in both large and small group markets. Visit www.myedge.biz for more information, or click on the sponsor link at ShiftShapersOnline.com. Today we're really excited to have a guest with us from the world of property and casualty. Interestingly enough, but as we talked off air, there are loads of crossovers and things that benefits advisors and others need to be aware of, and I think one side informs the other. So we're talking with Frank Pinaccio. Frank is partner and co-founder of Oceanus Partners. And with that, welcome, Frank.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you very much, David. A pleasure to be with you.
DavidWell, we thank you for spending some time and sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. You know, as I said in the open, Oceanus, your company, works primarily in the property and casualty space. But there are some crossovers, aren't there, between the property and casualty space and the benefit space that oftentimes are overlooked.
SPEAKER_01That's correct, David, and it creates quite a series of uh significant risks for the employers. What's a little bit paradoxical about especially workers' compensation, which is sold by property and casualty agents, uh typically almost exclusively. Well, workers' compensation is an employee benefit, but yet employee benefits agents typically, there's always exceptions to the rule, don't know very much about work comp. And what happens is when an injured employee goes out on workers' compensation, a whole host of risks arise if the employer doesn't know the steps to take, especially with respect to maintaining eligibility and also complying with either family medical leave or COBRA. The PC agent doesn't know how to advise around family medical leave COBRA, and in some cases, even Americans with Disabilities Act, throw that in there. And the benefits agent often doesn't know how to advise when an injured employee goes out on workers' compensation. So we have this big, huge gap in between. Benefits people not knowing work comp, yet it's an employee benefit, property and casualty folks, not really knowing how to maintain eligibility and other federal acts, yet they sell work comp, which is again an employee benefit.
DavidAnd you know, we try to provide tools for our audience to use. And so one of the things to understand if you're going to kind of try to learn more about this area and study up on is that by being deficient in these areas, it poses significant risks to your clients, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_01Well, it does. And I would assert, and often when we do training around this, people turn white as a sheet. I would assert that the following exists right now for many of the listeners of your podcast, David. That there are employees that are on a no-work status under workers' compensation. They're being paid their medical and lost-time benefits under work comp. However, if certain steps are not taken, they are no longer eligible to be on their health plan, even though premiums are being paid. If their dependents are on the plan, their dependents, of course, are no longer eligible to be on the plan. So even though premiums are being paid during this no-work status under work comp, and the actual injury, the medical that aligns with the injury from work comp gets paid, and all the other uh health conditions that may arise during this episode, the employer is likely the employee, and then of course the employer is likely going to find out that employee is not eligible to be on the plan.
DavidThere are some instances, as you know very well, that of benefit advisors who also either do property and casualty or who work in a property and casualty shop, or vice versa. They've got a benefit shop with a property and casualty specialist inside or a workers' comp specialist inside. How absent that kind of a scenario, how do you overcome this? How do you get both sides trained to the point where they understand how to talk to each other and how to best serve their client?
SPEAKER_01You know, that's a that's a very key and critical question because, and let me just say this, David, there's always exceptions, but I'm going to share what I see uh as I go across the country uh visiting agencies. Is in these agencies where there's benefits departments and property and casualty departments, there tends to be a cold chill between the two departments. The property and casualty folks are like, please don't mess up my property and casualty account. The benefit folks feel the same way. So they're very cautious. They're very, with few exceptions, they're they're very guarded about quote unquote their clients. It's not really their clients, it's the agency's clients. And to to best serve those clients, they should be working conjointly to close these big chasms that exist. But there's a lot of trepidation between the PNC folks and the benefits folks because there's a fear that the other side, the other department, is going to cause them to lose the account. Most times an unrealistic fear, but a fear nonetheless, which drives behavior. Um, and there's that that trepidation often leaves employers at significant risk.
DavidSo go back to the fundamental question here, which is if you've got that kind of a situation, and again, whether it's in-house or whether it's an outside counsel of the two disciplines, how do you bridge that gap? What's the step? If I'm a benefit advisor and I take to heart what you're talking about this morning and say, you know what, I do need to train up a little bit on this, and I and I maybe do need to reach out to the property and casualty folks. So if a claim happens, when we're advising the client, we can give them whole advice. How do I bridge that gap?
SPEAKER_01Well, let's let's take it from both sides. Uh the property and casualty folks, um, when they have a workers' compensation client, they need to be knowledgeable around family medical leave and cobra and eligibility provisions under the group health, so that they can talk that person through how to maintain their eligibility and other employee benefits when an employee goes out on a no-work status. I'm going to add one more piece to this, too, David. Another thing that happens with respect to the property and casualty folks is that they will frequently, oftentimes based on a request by the corporate officers, corporate officers in most states have the opportunity to exclude themselves from workers' compensation coverage, and many of them do, with the assumption that, well, you know, I'm not going to assume myself, I'm not going to file work comp benefits, but they could actually have a very serious injury. Usually the example is in an automobile accident. And the assumption is if I'm hurt arising out of the course and scope of employment, especially if it's catastrophic, uh, my group health insurance is going to pick that up. That may or may not be the case. So once again, we have uh P and C folks executing a policy where they may exclude the officers. The group health folks may have no knowledge that that's even been done or know so little about work comp. If I flip the tables, the group benefits folks to answer your question or to do my best to answer your question, need to become knowledgeable enough about work comp to know that officers can exclude themselves and ask that question so they make certain that the benefits are there when an officer is injured or rising out the course and scope. So I'm not, I it, I don't think it's either party's responsibility. It's both parties' responsibilities, and whether it's under one roof or whether it's different agencies, to pull together and help the employer, one, be aware of these risks and the gaps and the chasms and the what really are significant potential liabilities. And it's a process to help them close those gaps. It's it's not you don't have to buy more insurance, it's simply knowing the steps to take, David.
DavidWell, so salespeople, back to your earlier comment, it sounds like salespeople generally are more willing to take risks to avoid a loss. That is to say, please don't mess up my relationship with my clients. I don't want this other person in there, I don't want them talking to the client, etc., rather than to achieve a gain. Does that mean that the sales process that we're used to has to adapt?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. There have been significant uh discoveries in both neuroscience as well as behavioral economics over just the past handful of years. On the neuroscience side, we're we're learning because of the functional MRI machine. That can we can literally see people's brains light up. And it's the fight or flight mechanism, the oldest part of the brain that lights up first, that fear, that am I in danger? Is my survival at risk? Long before the, when I say long before, this of course happens in nanoseconds, but before the neocortex, the rational thinking brain gets engaged. There's also a gentleman by the name of Daniel Kahneman that won a Nobel Prize for identifying through his research that people are far more likely to change to avoid a loss than to uh secure or go after a gain. So, yes, what we we've now through research and through neuroscience have a far greater understanding of how people make change decisions, and we would assert that that is a salesperson's job, to facilitate a change decision, which people don't like to change. So your job is to facilitate a change. Many uh producers or agents like to approach the marketplace. Well, let me tell you what we can do for uh you, and let me tell you what you're gonna get, and let me tell you about my value-added services, a term I disdain, by the way. And and that does not connect because employers don't want to change and are less likely to change around what I'm going to get, but they're far more likely to change. You mean to tell me my entire net worth is at risk if I don't put this process in place? I'm curious about that. Tell me more.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. Want to find prospects in your area without cold calling, but with a warm introduction from a network relationship or from the prospect's accounting firm? How about finding companies that are out of compliance on their Form 5500 filing? What if you could find prospects that are paying more than standard compensation for their products and services? It can be difficult to find dependable business intelligence for both large and small group markets. With MyEdge, you'll have the ultimate unfair advantage. MyEdge makes it easy to create a pipeline of only qualified leads. You'll set yourself apart from the crowd when you know how to build a targeted value add strategy for the companies you want to work with. Clients and prospects always appreciate when their benefits consultants take the time to understand their employee benefits before they meet. Don't act and sound like everyone else. Learn more about this innovative prospecting solution by visiting www.myedge.biz or by clicking the sponsor link at shiftchhapersonline.com. Kahneman talks about it in a very interesting metaphor. He asks, you know, whether the process is inside out or outside in, which is kind of an interesting way to think about. And we we've spoken on the podcast before with other guests about the concern that we all like to think that the process in sales is intellectual first and emotional second. And I mean, I guess it's been your experience as well in these kinds of conversations that it's exactly the opposite.
SPEAKER_01It is exactly the opposite. We now can literally see that because of the functional MRI machine and see how messages move through the brain. And the neocortex, which makes us different from all the other mammals that we share this planet with, is big. It's huge. It really is a powerful part of the brain that allows us to think and rationalize and crunch data, but it's lazy. It doesn't want to turn on unless there's a trigger coming from the old brain or from the limbic system, which is your emotional part of your brain. If the flight or fight or emotional part of your brain doesn't trigger the neocortex, it's way too lazy to even think. So what ends up happening is agents and producers are firing messages at a neocortex that's not even turned on because it hasn't even been tweaked enough to find to decide, you know what, I'll burn some calories and start thinking because the message hasn't tweaked their fight or flight or triggered the emotional feelings that prompt the neocortex to turn on.
DavidThere are some changes, obviously, that are happening in the distribution channel that are also key to, and I think would serve benefits advisors and property and casualty brokers as well to kind of come together in a more united front, aren't there?
SPEAKER_01Significantly, yes. I mean, and it goes everywhere. People, of course, have probably already heard that Sam's Club's selling health insurance and overstock.com is is selling health insurance. We're having health care systems, hospital systems, now selling health insurance, either direct or through agents. But remember, that's how the travel industry used to do it before all the travel agents went away. Not all of them, the ones that specialize are still around that do very unique specialized things. And of course, the big buzz right now in the marketplace is zenfits and uh you know private equity, venture capital money is pouring into this space. They see inefficiencies. When uh money is it goes where money is treated well, and when you see $100 plus million dollars of uh private equity or venture capital money come into the insurance distribution space, it's because inefficiencies are being seen. It's because we have technology today that can do things that haven't been able to be done efficiently in the past, and you don't want to try to compete uh with a microprocessor. If that's if all you're offering is quotes and spreadsheets in your space, and I'm I'm sure you've spoken about this in your podcast over time, uh, you're in big trouble because there are so many different distribution channels. We haven't even mentioned the payroll companies, employee leasing companies. As Jimmy Durandy used to say, everybody wants to get into the act.
DavidWell, that's that's certainly more true today than ever before. But, you know, it's a natural progression, I think. We've spent the last 30 years, in essence, diligently, unwittingly perhaps working on commoditizing the product. And so, I mean, when you commoditize a product, all of a sudden the microprocessor becomes a whole lot bigger threat than when it was more of a personal product. And that's a great bridge to the next question, which is as you travel and you bring these deficiencies, for lack of a nicer word, to light with benefits advisors and also with the with the workers' comp folks that you go and see and you consult with, what's that conversation like? How does that conversation go when you're trying to get them to kind of make the turn and see that there are some new realities they need to deal with?
SPEAKER_01It goes across the spectrum. Of course, if you're 55 or 60 years old, you're just trying to pull the covers up over your head and hang on and try to get into retirement and maintain some level of uh equity in your agency. The younger folks don't have that option. Even middle-aged folks don't have that option because uh part of it is they hope this thing's gonna go away, but it's not gonna go away. Or they they're pointing fingers at affordable care. Affordable Care Act is not what I believe to be the largest driver in the changes on the benefit side. It's it's the future. As Jeff Bezos says, he didn't put independent bookstores out of business. The future did. And we have a very similar thing going on with respect to um technology and changes and distribution, and we're gonna see this dramatic change in health insurance where the healthcare systems themselves will be the insurer. They will be the risk taker. That's gonna be a dramatic change where insurance companies on the health side are likely gonna be the actuarial folks and the claims administration folks and the servicing folks, but not likely the risk takers. So, what we are trying to do is to essentially assert this. If you're keeping your head while others are losing theirs, you're probably misunderstanding the situation. This is an extraordinary, opportunistic time to be an agent. It's an extraordinary challenging time. We believe there's no better time to be an agent, though. It's just not going to be the same type of agent as in the past. And we're encouraging folks that, yes, pay attention to what's going on. Yes, you've got competition coming from areas, certainly not the agent down the street anymore. You've got 10 other distribution channels coming after you. Now, where are they vulnerable? They are vulnerable in that outside that commodity space. Go upstream, deal with more complexity, bring knowledge. The surveys that are being done with buyers today is what do you want from an intermediary? What do you want from a professional service advisor? And they're basically saying, lead me. Tell me something I don't know, look around the corner and lead me. And I would say this, David, that one of the biggest things that an agent can do today is take on a far greater role as a leader. There is a paucity of leadership in our profession. And if people will step up and lead as opposed to follow what has traditionally been done, they're gonna carve a path out there that will bring them rewards, not only financial, but emotional, intellectual rewards like they've never seen in their profession so far, so far. There's this is an extraordinary opportunity, but people have to climb up that learning curve, take on the challenges, and lead like they've never led before.
DavidSo, in the two or three minutes that we've got left, I always like to ask all of our guests how they envision the future. And I and the future's getting, you know, we when we used to talk about the future, we used to talk about 10 years from now. Now, sometimes I think we really ought to talk about 10 minutes from now the way things are changing. But you've talked a little bit about that in some of your answers. You've alluded to kind of the ACA model where the systems are going to be taking risk and they're going to be what we think of as the insurers of today, et cetera. Where do you see us in three years, let's say?
SPEAKER_01I see the agent has to be far more adept at understanding analytics. I'm not a nerdy geek, but I have a high degree of respect for actuaries and data analysts and data analytics folks and PhDs that do that kind of work. And due to the speed of the coprocessor, so going so fast now, due to uh data storage being practically free, the cloud is virtually free. We can store a gigabyte of information for three cents a gigabyte, where in the 1980s it was $200,000 per gigabyte. So now we have virtually unlimited data storage for almost uh for virtually no cost, no friction cost at all. So what where I see the insurance industry, especially in the benefit side, but really across the board, I shouldn't say especially the benefit side, across the board, predictive modeling, far more data analytics, we can today prove things that people assert to either be right or wrong. We can literally take a look at inside every single medical bill from a self-funded group health account, and we can verify what's working, what's not working. Are those network uh fee schedules actually lower or higher? What's going on with utilization? So we would encourage the agent and the producer, in order to be really effective for their clients on a moving forward basis, they need to begin to get comfortable with analytics. They don't have to know how to mine it, they don't have to know how to build uh algorithms around it. They need to be able to communicate what's going on in the world of analytics and begin to understand analytics in a way in which they can make recommendations. David, I think that's the big uh wave that's happening. And if agents will get up on the crest of that wave, they will certainly thrive in the marketplace moving forward.
DavidSo it's the the word is not plastics any longer. The word for the future is analytics. And I it's a great place to leave our discussion for today. Frank Pinaccio, partner and co-founder of Oceanus Partners. Frank, thank you so much for a really fascinating and kind of wide-ranging discussion. It's been it's been great.
SPEAKER_01It's been my pleasure. I appreciate the invitation. I enjoyed speaking with you, David. That's you and all of your listeners.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies, just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of shift shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the shift shapers to work in your business.