The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #48: What Do Employers Expect From Benefits Advisors? - With Michelle Jackson
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
A recent survey provided a glimpse into what employers want from their benefit advisors. The results offer a roadmap for savvy advisors to tailor their services to match up to those market expectations. What tools and techniques are needed to bridge that gap? That’s the question we asked Michelle Jackson, Senior Product Director at Zywave.
Michelle is a subject matter expert whose role at her company requires her to be a step ahead of advisor needs and broker trends. Market changes have driven employers to want more from their advisors. Advisors are balancing time constraints, the need for increased, in-depth, specific market, claim and plans knowledge in a lower commission environment.
Michelle believes that for advisors who can harness information and technology, the future seems especially bright. Join us to learn how you can match your client’s expectations and deal with your daily practice challenges. For a free copy of the 2014 Broker Services Survey, click the link below.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Insights from 2014 Broker Services Survey.
- The gap between what employers want and what advisors are delivering today.
- Why advisors need expertise across an incredibly wide range of regulatory programs.
- How market segmentation impacts what employers want.
One major solutions provider recently surveyed employers to learn what they really want from their benefit advisors. What did they learn and how can it help you to win more business? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Sultzman.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. Employee benefits, property and casualty, and financial professionals all rely on this affordable, easy-to-use, real-time search engine to find their target prospects in both large and small group markets. Visit www.myedge.biz for more information, or click on the sponsor link at ShiftShapersonline.com. As the markets have changed around us, we've spent some time on previous Shift Shapers podcasts talking about where brokers are, what they need to deliver, what the expectations are, and how you go about doing that in a way that doesn't eat your practice time alive and your ability to sell alive. And we thought we'd delve into that in a little more detail today. And we're really, really excited to have Michelle Jackson with us. Michelle is the senior products director at ZyWave. Many of you may know the company. They provide software as a service tools to advisors and agencies. And they've recently done a study that I thought would be a great jumping off point, and we'll make that available in a link on the website for you. But the study, they surveyed employers to try to get an idea of how they felt about what their brokers were delivering, not delivering, and what was important. And so I thought that would be a great starting point for today's interview. With that, welcome, Michelle. Thanks for spending some time with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, David.
DavidOne of the things that we talk about a lot on the program is that, especially with the advent of ACA, but if we're being honest with ourselves, even kind of before that, there's been a pretty concerted effort to disintermediate brokers from the process. And while some folks and regulators and whatnot may think that's a great idea, that's not what your survey showed employers wanted, is it?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. No. Employers are still looking to brokers, and now more than ever, to provide them with that accurate and timely information regarding various compliance issues, health care reform updates, of course, things are changing all of the time. I had a great opportunity to meet with a number of employers at a conference last summer, and many of them indicated that they would not consider leaving that broker relationship, potentially the relationship that they had, but not doing without an advisor in particular over the next three years. They really feel that things are shifting too quickly. HR resources at a number of employers are asked to do more with fewer resources. So they really are looking to that agency, that advisor, to be an extension of their company and help guide them and navigate them through all of the murkiness around all of these compliance and legislative updates that have been just um bombarding them over the past couple of years. And certainly they foresee that happening over the next uh potentially three years at least.
DavidAaron Powell Well, and and from the benefit advisor standpoint, we tend to focus an awful lot on ACA, but there are other sharks in the water out there that are things that benefit advisors need to be aware of, also, aren't there?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Absolutely. You know, I was uh in Florida last week and visiting with a number of our partners, some insurance agencies in that market, and you know, not only heard that commissions are are, of course, being restricted, being cut, there has to do more in many cases for less revenue, maybe thinking of new ways to generate revenue, but also there are outside influences that are really attacking that money that is on the table. So anywhere from carriers beginning to offer some of these value add services that brokers have been adopting over time and and really we see as becoming a requirement. Carriers subsidizing Ben Admin systems, for example. Analytics, some of the compliance and regulatory information, and and really forging a direct relationship with those clients to communicate that, especially in the small group market, but tending to get into those larger groups as well. We also see some other technology vendors getting in front of that client, sort of circumventing that uh insurance broker or advisor role to get in front of the client with uh various tools and products and taking a piece of AOR on those ancillary lines in particular related to those tools. So, you know, now more than ever, there's a great opportunity for brokers to really create stickiness and ensure their place in that relationship with the employer. But it is being recognized by other vendors, carriers, et cetera, as well as an opportunity. So just, you know, our advice to insurance brokers and advisors is really to take advantage of that opportunity and create the stickiness before those other threats come into play.
DavidYou're right. It certainly is a tremendous amount of plates to try to keep spinning all at once without letting any of them crash. And maybe what that tells us is that brokers and advisors need to go back to their initial focus. And I was interested in the study in the fact that there seems to be a gap between what employers want and what advisors are delivering. Are you seeing that in your conversations as well?
SPEAKER_00Yes, you know, on both the P and C and benefit side, so often those two arenas are related. You know, for years we've seen brokers really thinking that what their clients are interested in are, you know, how the prices that they can get, the amount of coverage for maybe the lowest price, and that's not necessarily the case. So while employee benefit challenges really do still hinge on managing those health care costs, compliance obviously is a huge requirement that folks need to be kept up to speed on, but also things like we saw employers really having some challenges around attracting and retaining employees. How can brokers help with adding to the culture of an employer, creating a benefits package above and beyond healthcare that may attract and retain more employees? Human resource issues beyond maybe PPACA, you know, stepping in to really serve as kind of a back office in terms of human resources is an opportunity that we see with the broker community. You know, obviously wellness and things like that still going on. But for the most part, we don't see an employer really looking to leave a broker because of a better quote somewhere else. We see them considering leaving a broker for lack of information, lack of tools, lack of guidance. And there's a lot of ways to automate those answers, the guidance in terms of compliance and so on, to really free the broker up to provide more detailed information and consulting in business practices.
DavidAaron Powell But it's not just ACA, is it? It's FMLA, HIPAA, Cobra, et cetera.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, yes. Those answers related to compliance around all of those legislative changes are the most important things for brokers, or I'm sorry, for employers right now in looking at their brokers. Communication still, helping employees make benefit decisions, understanding the benefits that are provided. There are a lot more options now than ever before to the healthcare consumer, and the brokers often asked to not only provide that compliance-related backing, but really help the employer and employee make the best decisions.
DavidIn your conversations, do you see that those things are changing from things that have traditionally been differentiators for benefit advisors and are now becoming almost required or table stakes to use that analogy?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. In terms of the compliance, I do believe that, you know, when I'm talking to brokers, they're telling me that their clients just expect that. So, you know, they expect to get timely updates on legislative changes. They they expect to get you know nice descriptions of what it means for me when a regulation is changed or added. And that is just, as you mentioned, the table stake. They need to do that to stay in business to keep relevant. Some of these other areas are maybe becoming the area that they could differentiate themselves in. So, how do I move, for example, from a broker who at open enrollment does a PowerPoint that includes various personas? You know, maybe I'm a 40-something-year-old married woman with children. This is a plan that maybe I would take. Maybe I'm a 25-year-old male, this is a plan that I would take. For example, moving away from something like that, which is kind of generic, typically the way folks have done open enrollment, into something that provides the employees a tool that they can use on their own time with their families to make very personalized healthcare decisions is an example of how things have shifted and how maybe one might delight an employer rather than just meeting a requirement.
DavidSo here's the rub for an awful lot of advisors, and and I see it with my consulting clients, I'll bet you see it with the folks that you talk to as well. When you start talking about all of these expectations that employers have and all the different things that you need to bring to the table today, I mean, I saw a study recently that the average salesperson spends only 37% of their time on direct sales and the rest of it on service. The folks you're talking to, when you go and you you talk to agencies and to groups of benefit advisors, are they worried that all of this is going to completely eat up their time and limit their selling time? And if so, I mean, what what kinds of tools are out there?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. That's to me the biggest hurdle in technology for agencies and something that I certainly spend a lot of my time trying to solve. You know, when you're talking to an insurance agent and you're saying, you know what, especially a smaller agency, in order to stay relevant, you need this CRM tool, you need this marketing and communications platform, you need this data analytics package, you need this Ben Admin system. Suddenly it's like, wow, you know, how am I am I gonna have to hire an additional person? This seems like a lot more work for me. When just the opposite, we want to develop tools to help take some of those things off that broker's plate. So doing that in a number of ways, you know, obviously mobile first development is a huge trend in technology so that folks can access different tools and services anywhere that they are. So that's something that's on, you know, all of our roadmaps. But beyond that, how can we make things simple? Taking something like a complex 70-page report of charts and graphs for analytics and boiling that down to a one or two page, very smart, you know, somebody used the term artificial intelligence with me on one of the things that that we're working on. Certainly I wouldn't go that far. We haven't mastered artificial intelligence, but boiling things down as as much as we can to make the job for that broker and that client easier with technology rather than adding to the complexity of their job with technology. When we think about what employers do, you know, they have their widgets to produce. They have to make sure that their widget is priced comparatively or competitively with the guy down the street. They need to make sure that their health plan offering is competitive with the guy down the street so that they can continue to hire and attract and retain the best talent. The insurance broker needs to worry about how that employer can protect and manage their risk. So they shouldn't have to worry about how to implement this tool or that tool. How can I best manage risk? And technology companies should keep in mind that they're to make those jobs easier. So, how can we, you know, from putting in 20-second, you know, on-screen videos about how to use a certain component so that it's no longer a struggle to go through setting up a campaign to let all of their users know about legislative updates in kind of a set it and forget it format? How can we suggest different components, not in terms of tools that we and others make, but in real terms as to what the need for the broker might be? So while right now it could seem to a lot of agencies like technology eats away more of their time, what I propose we'll see over the next uh year and beyond is really transforming those products, those previously differentiators, into something that helps the broker save time, become more efficient, run leaner so that they can continue to add more value to that employer to make them successful.
DavidNow, a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 Prospecting Solutions. The MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution makes it fast and easy to find the qualified leads you need to grow your business. Who uses the MyEdge Small Group Prospecting Solution? Employee benefits brokers who need to find accurate eligible employee numbers and employer contact information, property and casualty agents who need to know which employers are out of compliance with their fidelity bond, and if they need to increase their bond coverage, financial professionals who need to identify plan types, asset size, high commissions, and fees. MyEdge enables you to search for employers with 120 benefit eligible employees or fewer. By geographic region, employer contribution, employee participation, industry segment, and more. Register for a free live webinar at www.myedge.biz to see how easy it is to find qualified small group leads. Or click the sponsor button on the ChipShapersOnline.com website. So to kind of zero in on what you're talking about a little bit, maybe a two-part question or a question with two different considerations, what are the most popular things that you're seeing that you're being asked for and that you're seeing in the industry from the advisor community? And the second part of that, or to meld into that, is does it differ significantly in the different market segments, whether it's small or mid to large or self-funded brokers?
SPEAKER_00Sure. For I would say the one thing that is pretty consistent across all of our markets is a need for individual tools and calculators. So how can I very quickly help my group understand whether somebody is considered a full-time employee, you know, for example? So some very simple, mobile, easy-to-use calculators that can answer those basic questions that seem pretty easy on paper, but once you start to look at a seasonal employer, for example, calculating the number of full-time employees can be arduous. So, how can we take tasks like that or business continuity planning or you know, other of these little kind of quick hitting items that that can take a lot of time? How can we make those easy, available at one's fingertip and easy to use? That is across the board, something that that we've gotten a lot of requests for and are working on. Other things, especially in kind of the mid-market to larger group, is that there is such a push for self-funding these days. Folks, you know, employers maybe trying to get out of that pool environment for underwriting and really taking control of their own healthcare costs and looking at self-funding. So we're seeing plans, you know, with as few as 35, 50 potentially employees looking at self-funding. Now, I've been here at SIWA for 12 years, but prior to that was with Blue Cross Blue Shield of Wisconsin, which is now Anthem, working in their underwriting and actuarial departments. And, you know, in those days, we wouldn't have dreamed of putting a 35 life group on a self-funded plan. But that that is coming, it's happening now. And those groups in particular, because they are new to taking on that risk, we see analytics being huge. So, you know, for for years we've had analytics products, but making those relevant, simple, easy to understand, action-oriented is something that we're really seeing more and more of for that larger group market. Of course, also Ben Admin systems. How can we enroll groups in a way that's more efficient? You know, get away from paper enrollment, maybe integrate with payroll providers, take on some of that additional HR onboarding process from the employer. That's also being seen across the board, I would say, but especially for those employers that maybe are 50 lives and up.
DavidSo it's really almost in some instances a doing more with less kind of scenario and being able to hone in.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. That sums it up very, very nicely.
DavidMichelle, in the couple of minutes that we have left, I always like to ask folks, especially people in the in the software industry where you tend to need to see trends out into the future in order to stay viable as an enterprise, what do you see coming and what changes do you see? We've talked an awful lot about the near term, but let's say if we if you could use your crystal ball and look three years or even four years out, which is is, I know, an eternity in the in our industry these days. What do you see coming? What changes do you envision that might be coming down the road that advisors need to be aware of or in how advisors interact with clients beyond what we've talked about so far?
SPEAKER_00Sure. A couple of things come to mind. Um, one of the areas that we hear, you know, any technology vendor or any data provider talk about is integration. And that really is just going above and beyond and creating those efficiencies. So integration between suites of products, integration between different areas that an employer might have. So that could be just software tools. Or in my mind, because analytics tends to be my passion, my mind goes to integrating population health management for a particular employer. So we look at potentially work comp claims in a vacuum, we look at disability in a vacuum, we look at healthcare claims in a vacuum, and we tend to, you know, larger organizations tend to look at individual health and maybe engage in coaching for somebody who might be at a higher risk. What I see is moving forward, especially with the transient nature of our employee population, is really dealing with population health as a whole. And meaning taking a look at how wellness programs, disease management, different plan offerings, consumerism, how all of those things are impacting not only healthcare costs, but potentially workers' compensation costs, disability costs, presenteism, absenteeism. So I'm very excited to see data opening up more and more to be able to really harness that and offer solutions to brokers who can really work within a community to help you know potentially better the circumstance for a group of employers, for example, is something that I see on the horizon. Additionally, you know, really just making sure that brokers can level the playing field with those external threats. You know, there we've talked about a few of them, carriers, other technology vendors that may be seeking AOR for services. But in addition, you know, on the PC side, we're already seeing Google, Amazon, you know, we've seen the e-surance forever really taking a little bit more of the market each day. So it started with personal auto, may move into small commercial lines accounts going forward. A lot of times there's more alike than different with the P and C and benefits market. And I think we'll see that more and more on the benefit side. So just making sure that those value add expectations, and that's almost a contradiction, value add expectations, but really the value ads to me are becoming expectations, that those are met so that brokers can free up their time to really be consultants and advisors. So a little bit of it, even coming away from technology in that sense, using technology to make that part of the job more efficient, but going back to the basics and really understanding the business, the risk, and the employers' needs, I think is going to be a huge trend.
DavidAnd that's a great place to sum up for today. Michelle Jackson, senior product director at ZyWave. Michelle, thank you so much for sharing your insights with the Shift Shapers audience.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, David.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Shift Shapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the shift shapers to work in your business.