The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #46: How Retirement Plan Data Can Help Target Benefits Prospects - With Mark Smith
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today on The ShiftShapers Podcast, the founder and CEO of MiEdge, Mark Smith, returns to the show to continue our conversation about Big Data. In this episode, Mark focuses on the use of retirement plan data to create opportunities and deliver value to prospects and clients.
Mark describes new ways that benefit advisors can easily visualize potential prospect relationships from massive amounts of publicly-available data. We also discuss how you can interface your data findings with LinkedIn to help create offensive and defensive strategies that deepen and strengthen existing client relationships.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- The type of information the government collects.
- How this data can be used to play offense and defense.
- How large the data set is.
- How employers react to this type of research.
- Whether it is easy to see the relationships by just looking at the data.
- The important data points for advisors.
How can retirement plan information help you to target benefits prospects? And how do you sift through all of that data anyhow? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Chift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the chips in their industry. Get ready to become the chain that you want to study. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Saltman.
DavidToday's episode is brought to you by Code 64, a software platform that powers the entire consulting process for your benefits agency. Combine your industry expertise with proprietary data and compliance tools to deliver cutting-edge strategies and proposals that your clients and prospects will love. Today we're pleased to be speaking to Mark Smith. Mark, as some of you know, is the founder and CEO of MyEdge. And the reason that some of you know Mark, if from no other place than certainly from this podcast, is that Mark was one of our guests back in September on episode 24. If you haven't heard that episode yet, I think you'll find it interesting, especially in light of what we're going to talk about today. Back then we talked solely about using big data as a differentiator. We're going to touch on that, but Mark's got some thoughts on an area that you might not expect would be of interest to benefit advisors, and that's a way of thinking about and using to your advantage data from retirement plans. And we thought that would be an interesting follow-on conversation. So with that, Mark, welcome to the podcast.
SPEAKER_02David, it's honor to be here. Thank you for inviting me back.
DavidNow, traditionally, for medical plans, as I touched on in the opening, or health and welfare plans, if you prefer that nomenclature, retirement plan information was not something that was terribly useful. Why is it? I mean, how does that fit? It seems kind of a disconnect.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh, what's interesting uh about the whole uh kind of public disclosure documents that uh gathered at the various government agencies is that they typically are very much designed for the particular disclosure that you're providing to the government on that subject. So whether it be health and welfare for health and group life and disability, dental, etc., or retirement, or if you're a registered investment advisor and you're disclosing how much business you build, um, you know, there are all sorts of different data elements that reside. And so when you think about a particular set, you're only really thinking about it from that perspective. And we've really taken an approach that there's a lot of neat data that can be used to benefit all sorts of folks, and your audience being one of them.
DavidNow, all of this data is available publicly, isn't it? Correct.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. It's been that way for many years.
DavidAnd yet most of us don't know about it, many of us don't know about it, and many of us don't know how to use it. So let's level set for the folks for whom this might be a new discussion. What data is being collected across what different kinds of plans?
SPEAKER_02So there's a whole host of different data sets that are out there. Um we typically work predominantly with what's called the Form 5500s. And there's a couple of key elements to who files those forms. On the health and welfare side, typically it's for companies of 100 employees or greater, and they have to file a disclosure document that basically tells the government what plans they're offering: health, life, dental, disability, etc., how much they're paying, who their broker is, how much commissions are being paid, what their inord dates are, etc. On the retirement side, there's two types of folks that will file on the retirement side. If you have 120 or more participants, then you have to file what's called a large group plan, which is very similar to the health and welfare. It's an in-depth audited retirement filing. Um but there's also this form called uh short form, uh, which is filed for companies 120 employees or less. And that data set is one of the largest out there and uh is robust in terms of the type of information that uh that resides on it.
DavidSo let's dig into that a little bit. What information is there, first of all, if you could detail some of that, and then let's talk a little bit about why that's relevant to benefit advisors, because I know that even now, five minutes into our discussion, there are some benefit advisors who are scratching their head saying, Right, what am I going to use retirement data for?
SPEAKER_02Correct. Well, so if you think about from a from a benefit survisors perspective, everybody in the mother is going after that large group space. So that that 100 or more space, everybody's kind of focused on that. The large brokers and consultants, the boutiques, and then the small and mid-sized regionals are all going kind of after that large group space. What we found is that there's been a real void in quality information on the under 100 space, and particularly for ACA compliance in that 50 to 100 space. And so when you look at a whole host of different data sources, whether it be the kind of the DMBs, the Hoovers, the LinkedIns, the data.coms from the Salesforce world, you'll find that there's data that may or may not be up to date and certainly may or may not give you exactly what you're looking for in terms of a viable prospect that you want to uh you want to um take a look at. So what we found with this data is that you have really accurate, up-to-date information because number one, you can prospect identify and you use a search engine kind of format. So as we spoke earlier, this data is public, but it's public in individual formats. So you would have to know the name, you'd have to type it in, and then you could digest that data in a way that's kind of on a big PDF form. What we have is uh is a way for you to just slice and dice that data in terms of global perspectives. So if you want to, in your geographic area, want to find every employer between 50 and 100 employees, you would be able to do that. And then you'd be able to look at an accurate number of employees that's based upon benefit-eligible participants. So again, we kind of strip out not including part-timers, things like that. This is gonna be, you know, especially in that ACA world, you're gonna be looking at kind of typically full-time benefit-eligible participants as the number that you want to go after. And so when you think about all the other data sources out there, they tend to give you a range like you know, 25 to 250 employees or 50 to 250, or something like that. We give you a very accurate look at how many benefit-eligible employees there are. Obviously, in addition to that type of data, you've got the contact information, the address information, the industry segmentation. And so you can very easily laser in and find a starting point for viable prospects for you to digest.
DavidNow, you work with a lot of benefit advisors in all different size firms. How do they use this data? And look, we'll we'll take this in two sections. I'll ask first, how is this data, because I think it's maybe the more obvious, how is it used in in an offensive capacity?
SPEAKER_02So on an offensive strategy, you're looking to find things about that prospect that you can at least have a conversation with that client in a meaningful way. So the first thing to do is obviously to know who who you need to be speaking to. So the contact and all of these contacts are going to be fiduciary level and above, and they're typically at this size going to be the business owner that you would have the contact for. We then have our LinkedIn capability where you can triangulate LinkedIn with a one-click and determine how you might be connected to that account for purposes of center of influence building. But then we kind of give you a whole set of information indicators to determine is this a viable prospect for me? Um, and is it something that I want to be looking for? So let's take an example of uh an ACA compliant type of approach. So you're looking really for 50 to 100 employees, then we we give you a participation ratio. So, how many of those employees are actually participating in their current retirement benefits? A high participation ratio, so 80, 90, 100%, would indicate that there is a high percentage of those employees that are being enrolled in their retirement plan. That would indicate then on the health and welfare side that there's likely to be a health and welfare program, and there's likely to be employer engagement in that health and welfare program. On the flip side of that, if there's a low participation ratio, lower than 75, lower than 50%, and you combine that with no employer contribution, and because we we're able to identify that for you pretty easily as well, then that would indicate that maybe they're just offering a retirement program, but really there's no employer engagement in it. And so they're gonna have potentially no health and welfare plan or particularly low-level benefits for that employee group. And so that clearly is gonna need a benefit advisor's help to comply with many of the aspects of ACA. First of all, offering benefits, and secondly, offering them at the level that's acceptable to the government.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, Code 64, the industry-leading software platform that powers the consulting process for your benefits agency. In this new era of benefits consulting, competition, healthcare reform, and rising costs have all made the health insurance industry complicated. As the trusted advisor, do you find yourself behind a computer researching new regulations or reinventing presentations rather than meeting with clients? There is a better solution. It's the Benefits Consulting Cloud at Code 64. Begin by engaging new prospects with up-to-date industry insights or surveying employees for feedback on their benefits offerings. Upload census data to analyze thousands of criteria and uncover benchmarks against similar employers to see how your client's plan stacks up. Impress your clients with proprietary branded consulting materials to deliver a game plan unique to your agency and your clients' needs. Maximize the efficiency of your agency and delight your clients by delivering the best advice in half the time with the Benefits Consulting Cloud at Code 64. So let's take the flip side of that coin. If I'm an advisor, how can I use a tool such as this for defensive purposes to help me hang on to my book and to know what's going on in the marketplace?
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, from a defensive perspective, you you obviously the first things to do is to search for your existing relationships. And using this, you can identify many of those key indicators. Another big indicator we have, which is on the compliance side, to do with the fidelity bond, you may or may not know that to be in compliance for your fidelity bond, you need to have 10% of your beginning year assets in the form of a fidelity bond. Well, what's really um astounding to me is when we did the analysis, about 12% of all employers out there are out of compliance. Either they don't have one or they're below that 10% threshold. And so, from a defensive perspective, you want to make sure that your current clients aren't in a compliance issue, and then coming back on the offense side of it, it's also another strategy to pick up the phone to that person to have conversation that is a little more meaningful to them, and then obviously to offer many of our benefit advisors are offering a free compliance audit. So when you think about the fact that this is a fairly low-level type of compliance issue that can trigger an audit, but it's still hanging out there. What else in their you know, plethora of other compliance-oriented issues are there? And that's a conversation that the that owner of the company might be clueless as to how to answer. And so then your ability to offer a free compliance audit on not just that component, but also all the other components to do with ACA and ERISA and many other things are uh is a is a really powerful strategy that uh the benefit advisors have been very successful with.
DavidWell, and that dovetails into my next question. It's typical in a lot of other industries that before a professional would go out and talk to a prospect, they've thoroughly researched the company and perhaps the company's owners or founders or shareholders or whatever the form might happen to be. In the benefits advising arena, it's a little bit of a kind of a new thing. What kind of feedback are you getting about how clients and prospects are reacting to that? Are they taken back? Are they surprised? Are they happy, grateful? What are you hearing?
SPEAKER_02Well, there's a whole mixed bag, David, and I think it's a similar response to when you kind of show any sensitive information to anybody. There's the folks that will immediately say, Oh, wow, that's amazing. Can I see more? What else? You know, kind of they they really are embracing of the fact that they want to know more. And then there's a fair proportion of folks out there that this scares them to death. And so they immediately shut down and they immediately kind of um go on the back foot with regards to you know putting up the shutters, and they're like, No, I don't want to hear this, I don't want to know this, you know. So you you've really got to kind of be sensitive as to how much and how aggressive you are with disclosing all of this stuff right out of the bat when you don't necessarily know that person that you're talking to. And that's where you know the concept of trying to find a friendly introduction into that relationship where you can have a candid conversation that's not defensive right out of the gate, is an important component to building the ability to then put yourself in a in a good place with that prospect and eventually then turn that into a client.
DavidWell, and that that goes back to the discussion about LinkedIn and one of our very first podcasts when we started this about a year ago, we talked to Mel Schlessinger, who's an expert in using LinkedIn for leveraging to get those kinds of warm referrals. So it's interesting that we've spoken about LinkedIn in today's conversation as well, because that you're right, that would soften that a little bit. Do you see, as this becomes more accepted and more quote unquote normal, more the course of business, do you see this as being something that ends up being table stakes to open a relationship? In other words, if you haven't done this kind of research, you won't really be welcomed or looked on as a real in-depth professional?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think that any business owner that is gonna take anybody seriously is first of all gonna listen to friendly people to ask for their opinions on who they should talk to and those kinds of things. But when it comes to it, you have to present, sound different, and sound very smart about what it is that you're bringing to the table. And a lot of that starts with doing a lot of research and understanding what it is that you're getting into before you walk in the door, but then being smart enough to react to whatever it is you're hearing through that conversation and come up with those critical solutions that really uh are what's going to turn that prospect discussion into a client.
DavidSo you see having this knowledge and having done this research at least for a while as continuing to be a differentiator for firms and advisors that employ it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, obviously I'm biased because I live in this world, but I I've been on the benefit advisor world for many, many years, and I know how difficult that job is. And the hardest part is to first of all find qualified prospects that fit the makeup of how you want to build your business, then having an intelligent conversation with that decision maker, and then creating solutions that you can solve their problems, and and all of those components have to align for any of these to turn into business. And so, if you can make that process easier, that can only help the situation. And so using a tool and certainly a technology tool that can take huge amounts of data, make sense of it, find those targeted, low-hanging key indicators within all of that data is a huge part of taking away the workload that used to exist for folks, and now you can then turn your attentions onto the hard part, which is building those resources, those trusted introductions, and of course your value proposition uh that you can bring to that particular client.
DavidMark, in the in the couple of minutes that we have left today, uh we always like to ask our guests how they envision within their realm of subject matter expertise, how they envision the future. Where do you see this going? Obviously, there have been great steps going from 5,500 data that's you know, you have to plow in and try to parse yourself and you have to be clever enough to see the relationships to where we are today. Where do you see it going in the next two, three, four, five years?
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, there's a huge amount of data that's sitting out at a whole host of various sources. So, in this data set alone, for example, there is you know over 650,000 companies in just this, what we call the small group uh retirement data set. On the large group side, you know, to by comparison, there's about 50,000 or so companies across the country that file on that large group side. So this data set is huge, and then on a combined basis, that's a lot of companies. Where I see this going is that you've got to get really good at triangulating other sets of information to couple onto this information to create a much more robust set of information from all the various data sources out there, and then creating some analytics around that that can perhaps predict the future as best as you can, or at least take some of those indicators and put flags on them to say, hey, this looks like it's gonna turn into something you might want to get on this and kind of make those early decisions now to get ahead of the competition. But I think that anybody out there that's not embracing the magnitude of data that sits out there is gonna be behind the curve because people are getting quicker, faster, and more sophisticated every single day.
DavidNo question. That's a great place to leave our conversation today. Mark Smith, founder and CEO of MyEdge. Mark, thanks for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience. Once again, we love having you.
SPEAKER_02That's my pleasure, and thanks again for inviting me back.
DavidThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of the Saltzman Group. We work with entrepreneurs, executives, and companies just like you, to help shape the shifts in your business. To schedule a 20-minute call to learn more, visit our website at thesaltzmangroup.com or call me directly at 803-386-8005. I'd love to hear from you. And while you're on our site, you can also click the podcast tab for the entire catalog of Chip Chapers episodes and to access some really great special offers. Give me a call at 803 386 8005 and learn how to put the secrets of the chip chapers to work in your business.