The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #42: Critical Illness Insurance Adds Value to Your Client Conversations - With Ken Smith
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
When your client is diagnosed with a critical illness, will they have ready access to a lump sum of money needed to cover the ever-increasing personal responsibility of their benefit plan? How would you advise them to pay for costs that aren’t covered by their medical coverage? Critical Illness (CI) insurance offers a solution. In this episode, subject matter expert Ken Smith helps us to understand the product.
Ken is a Director at Assurity Life and is the co-author of HIAA’s book, Supplemental Health Insurance. In this fast-paced conversation, you will learn about the various types of CI, how to incorporate the coverage into the medical plans you are already providing and how to approach clients about the subject.
Click the SPECIAL OFFER button on the right for a free white paper that will help you learn more about positioning this solution in your practice. Click the Assurity logo to email Ken.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Ken’s background.
- The history of Critical Illness and how it works.
- How the product is underwritten.
- The strategic use of an Accident Plan in combination with Critical Illness coverage.
- How advisors can position this with their clients.
- Whether the plans pay out for recurring conditions.
What strategies can you use to help clients manage the ever-increasing personal responsibility of today's plan designs? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the chips in their industry. Get ready to become the change that you want to succeed. Here's your host and chip transformation strategist, David Salton.
DavidToday's episode is brought to you by Code 64, a software platform that powers the entire consulting process for your benefits agency. Combine your industry expertise with proprietary data and compliance tools to deliver cutting-edge strategies and proposals that your clients and prospects will love. Today we're really excited to be talking with Ken Smith. Ken is director at Assurity Life. He's also co-author of HIA's book, Supplemental Health Insurance. And today we're taking advantage of Ken's kind of deep expertise in the often overlooked area of critical illness insurance. With that, good morning, Ken.
SPEAKER_00Good morning, David. Thanks for having me today.
DavidWell, thanks for spending some time with the Shift Shapers audience. We appreciate being able to tap into your expertise. Speaking of which, give us a little bit of your background and kind of how you got so interested in CI.
SPEAKER_00It's an interesting story. Back in the 90s, I was at Mutual of Omaha, and one of my responsibilities was supplemental health products, one of which was a couple cancer plans. And we had to make a decision whether we were going to expand the cancer business and develop a new product or get rid of it. And I just happened to stumble across everything that was happening with critical illness around the world. And just thought, with all the changes that have taken place, this product is a is a great fit.
DavidWell, critical illness is kind of a good news, bad news story, isn't it? I mean, uh the good news is we're surviving illnesses longer. The bad news is the cost of treating those are going up. Is that what critical illness was meant to address?
SPEAKER_00It was it was really when Dr. Bernard created the product back in 1983, one of the things with it was he started to see that with the advances in medicine, people were surviving where they died. And what really happened was he had patients who he said, as a doctor, he was able to heal them physically, but the financial stress was working against everything he was doing as a doctor and killing his patients. So he came up with this idea of a policy that would pay a lump sum on the diagnosis of one of the covered conditions. And he started talking to insurance advisors, he started talking to insurance agents. Um 1983, Crusader Life introduced the first critical illness plan, and it spread around the world. Critical illness insurance is sold in over 60 countries around the world today.
DavidAnd Dr. Bernard is not an American, although people may be familiar with the name. He's the brother, is he not of the famous heart surgeon, Dr. Christian Bernard?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he was part of that team of surgeons that did the first successful human heart transplant back in 1967.
DavidSo is critical illness still a bigger product overseas than it is in the United States?
SPEAKER_00Yes. It's funny, David. I tell people that, you know, if you look, if something is originates in the U.S., we are fast adapters. But in many cases, if it's coming from other places around the world, we're slow adapters. And I think that's the case with critical illness. One of the other things that has happened in this country is in the other countries, the carriers, the companies, have invested a lot of time in sales training for the advisors. And, you know, one of the challenges we've had is we're so hung up on product that we don't talk about what the product does enough.
DavidIsn't that the truth? That's true across an awful lot of products, unfortunately. But I guess the lower adoption rate in this country is good news for our audiences because it represents an opportunity for them. So with that in mind, talk us through a kind of a primer on critical illness for those listeners who might not be familiar with it. What are the components? What is it? How does it work?
SPEAKER_00It's really simple. It's one of the easiest products to work with. Basically, you know, the critical illness plans cover cancer, heart attack, stroke, and generally 10 or 12 other conditions. And what happens is if I buy a $25,000 critical illness plan, I'm diagnosed with cancer, I'm going to get a check for $25,000. It's just as simple as that. And, you know, I'm diagnosed with cancer. You get a pathology report. The pathology report says either I have cancer or I don't have cancer. The only claim that's easier to work with is a life insurance claim.
DavidBecause if you don't fog the mirror, they send the check.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Or you get the death certificate, and it's and for the audience, David, I think the most important thing to remember about critical illness is what it really does is it's designed to reduce the financial stress when someone has a critical illness. I mean, it's just really that simple. You know, 99.9% of the time there's going to be financial stress. 100% of the time there's going to be emotional stress. And what the critical illness does, if you can reduce that financial stress, it's going to help reduce that emotional stress.
DavidNow, is it typically a medically underwritten product?
SPEAKER_00Typically it is. A lot of the products out there are pretty much a simplified issue. You know, you answer the health questions, no, you fit within the bill chart, the product is issued.
DavidAnd is it an individual product, a group product, a list bill product, or both?
SPEAKER_00All of the above.
DavidOkay, so it can be used in a variety of different situations.
SPEAKER_00To meet a variety of different needs.
DavidAll right. So if I'm an advisor working with individuals, I can just sell it individually. Is there a minimum number if I'm working with groups and I want to list bill the product?
SPEAKER_00Typically, five is the is the minimal on the list bill.
DavidDo you get any concessions on medical underwriting in a list bill situation?
SPEAKER_00With uh with the larger groups with participation, there's a uh guaranteed issue is fairly common.
DavidAnd and what are generally speaking the parameters for that? What size group and what participation do you need?
SPEAKER_00Generally a group of 50, 20% participation, and you can have a guaranteed issue of 5,000 with that.
DavidAnd is that employer paid or individual paid, or does it matter?
SPEAKER_00It doesn't make any difference.
DavidInteresting. Interesting. So it's got a lot of range and ought to be applicable for almost anyone's practice who wants to adopt it.
SPEAKER_00Correct.
DavidAnd I know that nobody's really interested in this, but what's the typical commission structure of a CI plan?
SPEAKER_00It tends to be on agent level, you're looking at 60% with pretty healthy renewals to go along with it.
DavidInteresting. Now I've I've heard this from a number of people who think that critical illness is kind of like disability income's little brother. Is that a decent analogy if brokers want to start thinking about this?
SPEAKER_00I actually look at it as um it it there's a fit with disability. I'll give you an example, David. If I have a 90-day elimination period on my DI policy, it's gonna be 120 days before I get my first check. In a lot of cases, if I'm diagnosed with cancer, I've got that 90-day elimination period, I'm gonna be back at work before I can my disability kicks in. So it can fit together with disability there. Where the one of the biggest fits is, is basically with health insurance. You look at the plans that are out there now with their high out-of-pocket cost, and you look at the fact that there's a lot of expenses, like with cancer, that are not going to be covered with the health insurance. You know, the Emerging Cancer Society mentions that two-thirds of the costs related to critical or to cancer are not covered by health insurance. And you start adding those up together with the deductibles and the co-pays, our clients can have a can can face some pretty serious problems with a critical illness.
DavidAll right, so let's move from theory and and and kind of book learning into strategy and tactics, which is where everybody lives. I've been reading some of the things you've written about critical illness, and you make a very interesting analogy to 1965. Would you share that with the audience?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's been interesting, is you know, with everything that's happened with ACA, I've seen the last year, I would estimate I've seen 20% of the agents leave the business. They're not happy with commissions, there's a lot of moving parts to deal with with ACA. I remember when I started in the business talking with some of the old timers, and they were telling me way back when Medicare was first passed in 1965, how people predicted that that was the end of the health market for seniors. And you stop almost 50 years later and look around with how the senior health market has grown tremendously with Medicare, with Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage.
DavidSo for people who are kind of hand-wringing and thinking the end is near, maybe that's a great lesson to take forward into the future in this post-ACA environment.
SPEAKER_00There is, I believe there's tremendous opportunity. In a lot of cases, we may not know what it is, but I believe there's going to be tremendous opportunity in this market.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, Code 6.4, the industry-leading software platform that powers the consulting process for your benefits agency. In this new era of benefits consulting, competition, healthcare reform, and rising costs have all made the health insurance industry complicated. As the trusted advisor, do you find yourself behind a computer researching new regulations or reinventing presentations rather than meeting with clients? There is a better solution. It's the Benefits Consulting Cloud at Code 64. Begin by engaging new prospects with up-to-date industry insights or surveying employees for feedback on their benefits offerings. Upload census data to analyze thousands of criteria and uncover benchmarks against similar employers to see how your client's plan stacks up. Impress your clients with proprietary branded consulting materials to deliver a game plan unique to your agency and your clients' needs. Maximize the efficiency of your agency and delight your clients by delivering the best advice in half the time with the Benefits Consulting Cloud at Code 64. Now I know one of the opportunities and one of the strategies that you instruct on is using CI in combination with accident insurance. So let's kind of take a step back. I mean, I think a lot of people may think they know what accident insurance is, but give us a quick definition and then we'll talk a little bit about how that might be applied in someone's practice.
SPEAKER_00Typically, I'm and we're talking about an accident medical expense that after a deductible reimburses for the actual expenses related to the accident. I mean, just simple, pretty much straightforward.
DavidOkay, so if we use these two products in combination, tell me how that works in terms of the practicality of it and the nuts and bolts, and then let's talk a little bit about what that advisor's conversation might be with a prospect, whether it's an individual prospect, and also if it differs, how it might go with a group prospect or client.
SPEAKER_00Okay, with the products together, I really encourage the advisors to package the an accident medical expense together with the critical illness. On the individual side, you start to look at the metal plans. You know, you're looking at high deductibles, you're looking at high out-of-pocket cost. And with the critical illness together piece with that, is you're looking at covering those deductibles, co-pays, all that. But there's also a number of costs that are not covered by health insurance, which I just mentioned. And the products, there's really two things you're doing when you put those products together with the metal plans, is you are really reducing the risk. And essentially, you know, our job is to reduce the financial stress for our clients. And the combination just works great.
DavidSo what's the market penetration? I mean, do you are a lot of brokers embracing the strategy?
SPEAKER_00You know, it's interesting, David. There are, I would guess, 40 to 50 percent of the individual brokers are packaging the products together on a regular basis. There's still an incredible opportunity with the 50% that are not doing it. It just makes so much sense.
DavidSo let's talk a little bit about what the conversation is. And I'll kind of ask the question twice, if you will, so we can zero in on this. First, let's talk about what the conversation is if I'm an advisor and I'm sitting across the table from an individual prospect or an individual client. How do you school advisors to have that conversation?
SPEAKER_00The easiest way is with questions. And, you know, I would ask the question, David, if you exceed your deductible, what do you think would be the reason? And typically the response I get is accident or cancer. And that's a great way to open the discussion there.
DavidAnd on the group side, whether it's uh an employer paid or an employee paid, is that conversation a little bit different?
SPEAKER_00It still comes back to using that question to help them see the need, is that you know, on the group side, they've got so much an exposure out there. And then the question is on the group side, would you be able to write a check for that amount if you had cancer or you had an accident? And most people say no. And then even if they say they can write a check, would you rather protect yourself for $2 a day or write the large check? It's just really as simple as that.
DavidThere are a number of carriers, yours included, who have critical illness plans. Generically speaking, if an advisor is going out to try to find a plan that they want to bring to market, that they want to bring to their prospects and clients, what should they look for? What constitutes what you would say is a good high-quality CI plan versus other things that may be in the market?
SPEAKER_00Number of cover conditions. The second thing is drill down and look at the definitions. And the more encompassing the definitions are, the better the plan is going to be. The biggest thing is you have the cancer, heart attack, and stroke covered. That's the bottom line.
DavidNow, when you say more encompassing the definitions, you and I, I mean, I'm an old DI dork, and I think you know that about me. So we're used to kind of talking about definitions. But for our audience, and in the CI scenario, what's a good definition? What would be a bad definition?
SPEAKER_00Okay, the I I'll use the the cancer, the cancer definition. And um, you know, for example, with, and I'm gonna I I don't want to bring a shirti in, but I'll use a surety as an example with this. If you look at our cancer definition, there are cancers that would be covered under our plan that we would pay 100% with that would not a lot of other carriers would not pay or only be covered a partial amount. Stage one Hodgkins is a is a great example of that. It's not specifically excluded under the 100% benefit on our plan.
DavidDo most high-quality plans or do any plans at all offer uh what I would call a restoration of benefits? So if I'm a claimant and I have either a, and let's look at this in two ways, either a recurrence of the same condition or a different condition, does the plan just pay once and then I'm I'm out, or do I have opportunities to claim more than once?
SPEAKER_00Most of the individual plans pay once. And you know, they'll only pay for uh the covered condition one time. On the group side and the work site side, you tend to see more plans that have a restorative benefit after they've been cancer free for a certain amount of time, they will be covered at a reduced benefit for any other cancers.
DavidNow, are are these plans typically in a group in a group setting? Are these plans typically portable?
SPEAKER_00Yes.
DavidInteresting. So no matter if I decide it's important to me and I want to buy it and I leave the employer, I can take it with me, I can keep it. Does the premium change when that happens?
SPEAKER_00No, the premium stays the same.
DavidInteresting. Interesting. So we've got uh just a couple of minutes left, and I'm interested in your view of what you see the future being, both in terms of the takeup rate, how this fits with advisors practice, and then where you see critical illness going in in the near and midterm.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's interesting, David. One of the things that I've seen this last year is with advisors, if most of the advisors that are successful do one thing and do it well. And if you ask them to do anything outside their comfort zone, it tends to be a challenge. And where we have had the success with critical illness, we're starting to see it with some of the old DI guys, is basically rather than treating it as a separate sale, using it as a package together with the health insurance to address the same problem, looking at it as it's part of the solution together with the health insurance to solve, to pay those medical expenses, to reduce the financial stress. Um so if an advisor looks at it as part of the solution, their perspective on the product changes totally, and it's easy to incorporate into the pro sales process.
DavidI'm curious, in your experience, are there advisors who are using this as the sole focus of their practice?
SPEAKER_00No. There are very few in the US market who I would say have committed more than 30% of their time on selling critical illness.
DavidAnd again, from your experience, what would you say is the current penetration if you took the universe of benefit advisors at 100%? How many of them are talking to their clients about this product or the combination?
SPEAKER_00Okay, the I I would say of the total universe, probably somewhere in a neighborhood of 15 to 20 percent.
DavidInteresting. So there's loads of opportunity out there.
SPEAKER_00There's incredible opportunity. There's an incredible opportunity. The challenge for the benefit advisors is in a lot of cases, we've been selling product and price for so long to make that shift that I just mentioned previously and look at this as a part of the solution, not just the product.
DavidKen Smith, Director at Assurity Life and an expert on critical illness and accident insurance. Ken, thank you so much for sharing your expertise with the Shift Shapers audience today.
SPEAKER_00My pleasure, David. Thank you.
DavidFor more information about this episode, or about any of our earlier episodes, and to learn how to subscribe on iTunes so you never miss an episode. Go to our website, ShiftShapersonline.com. While you're on the site, leave a comment and register to be part of the Shapers community. You'll be the first to learn about upcoming specials, like exclusive webinars, and content you can use to take your business to the next level. Again, thanks for joining us for today's episode. And remember, you have the power to shape the shift in your business.