The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #30: New Strategies To Keep Employees Educated, Empowered and Energized – With Phil Wilkins
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Today, we are very pleased to speak with Phil Wilkins, director of Partner Development at GuideSpark. Phil is an expert on the subject of modern communication strategies and he shares his thoughts on new strategies to communicate important benefit concepts to employees.
In this era of communication immediacy, multimedia strategies have begun to replace paper booklets and often, enrollment meetings. More than three quarters of all Internet users today engage with videos as a means of learning. Tune in to learn about using these new tools to create emotional connections that engage today’s employees.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- Why employee engagement is so important.
- Whether paper is now a dead medium for communicating with employees.
- The importance of making an emotional connection with employees.
- How to deliver engaging content on the device an employee chooses.
- How benefits advisers can use this information to differentiate themselves in today’s market.
As attention spans get shorter and shorter, what are the best ways to keep employees educated, empowered, and engaged? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode of Shift Shapers is sponsored by MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 prospecting solutions for benefit advisors. Local, regional, and national advisors rely on this affordable, easy-to-use real-time search engine to find their target prospects. For more information, visit our website at www.shift shapersonline.com. Today we're very excited to be speaking with Phil Wilkins, who's Director of Partner Development at GuideSpark, which is a company that uses what we broadly know as explainer videos to help advisors. And it's a whole new world with videos and brochures and what we do and how we communicate and why communication is so important. And Phil's an expert on the subject, and we're pleased that he's taking some time to chat with us this morning about all of those things. Good morning, Phil.
SPEAKER_02Good morning, David. And uh thanks for using the word expert uh very, very loosely.
DavidWell, I think it applies, and I think our listeners will find that out by the end of the interview. Give us a quick synopsis of your background.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so um, you know, I've been in some form of communications for the better part of the past uh nine years. In my previous life, working with a major Fortune 500 company, Thomson Reuters, really working with really investor relations marketing and internal communications folks at some of the world's top companies like Exxon, Starbucks. And one of the things that was always interesting was that companies, regardless of shape and size, invested so much in communications, yet they was kind of like the blind leading the blind in most cases. And what was really intriguing about moving over to GuideSpark, which uh you know is a really, really fast growing startup, was that we were always looking at how does the data create the content for us? How do we actually provide something of value uh to clients? So I love communications. It's been who doesn't love talking to people? Um and and I guess uh I'm one of the lucky ones that gets to do that every day and hopefully you know helping some companies and even more importantly now my role with brokers, helping them bring a solution to the table. That's one of a kind, and that's something that uh makes it exciting to get out of bed every morning.
DavidWe'll dive down into some of the um the specifics of kind of where all of this comes from and the granular part of it. But at the top end, aren't we really talking about employee engagement? And and if you agree with that, why is that so important today?
SPEAKER_03You know, I I don't think that employee engagement is something new forever, as long as I've been in business at least. Companies have struggled with how do they effectively get employees to have an emotional connection. If you think about the dictionary definition of employee engagement, it's an emotional connection that an employee has to their company's brand and values. So if you think about um why that's important, you see, you know, we've we've heard so much about the war of talent is over and the talent has won. The reason the talent is won is because we live in this modern era where everything is at your fingertips and um the choice is really up to you as an employee. So as an employer, you gotta really get rid of the one-way institutional era type of communications. And it's really gotta be an open conversation, especially as sort of the baby boomers are starting to retire, and you've got this new population of millennials coming into the workforce who want constant feedback, they want information short, and so it's really applying what they're doing in their personal lives and bringing it to life behind the enterprise.
DavidSo if employee engagement isn't something new, yet we're bringing new ways of communicating with employees, it's the employees who've changed?
SPEAKER_03I think a portion of it has been that. I also think that, you know, the more there's this sort of modern era, we we we talk a lot at GuideSpark about sort of human connections, being real, being honest, not hiding behind paper. Engagement is a is a really big piece of helping employees make sure that their sort of career, health, and wealth are all taken care of and they feel that they can stay with a company long enough that it'll affect them positively, and it's not just a paycheck.
DavidSo if we're moving away from an era of paper manuals and paper brochures to more immediate kinds of communication that resonate more with today's consumers, what are you finding as you go company to company? What are you hearing from the compliance folks who a lot of them seem still stuck on if it's not on paper, it's not real? Do you struggle with that? Is that a is that an issue that you guys work with?
SPEAKER_03I think in some cases, absolutely. You know, I don't view communications and you know, multimedia communications as a total replacement for paper. It's just another avenue to communicate with your employees. More importantly, it's a measurable avenue of communications. You know, where we deal with a lot of brokers and consultants in the benefit space specifically, where they're spending tens of thousands of dollars on printed resources. Yet I only know for myself, you know, those things end up being doorstoppers. And from a company, if you're gonna spend tens of thousands of dollars, you want to know whether or not it's effective. How many times has an employee sat in a face-to-face enrollment session, read the brochure, and still have questions like, what does the word deductible mean? The brokers out there are probably laughing right now as they're listening to this because that's something very, very common, I'm sure, but it's just a way to bring it all to life.
DavidWhat works best? I mean, we've all seen, I'll go back to the phrase I used earlier, explainer videos. And some of them are just narrated PowerPoints. Some are done well, some are done terrible, just like most PowerPoints are. Some are animation, some are those whiteboard images with the hand drawing. What do you find works best in communicating benefits to employees?
SPEAKER_03I think it's a couple things. First and foremost, you gotta lose the jargon. That is something that, you know, for us when we look at uh the studies among employees, you know, if you look at annual enrollment, we just did a study of about 500 companies. 73% wished they had an easier way to communicate and engage with their employees. And a piece of that is bringing a human element to it. I think on the on the other side is it's gotta resonate with the brand. You know, companies spend millions of dollars and countless hours building a human capital strategy. What good is that strategy if the people you're building it for don't understand it? And that's what it's always got to tie back to is what does this mean for me as an employee at ABC Company? And how does that make me more connected and involved in the organization? And so it always has to come back to bringing that human element and just having a real conversation and losing, you know, the jargon that unfortunately is just all over the place.
DavidSo when you're thinking about fashioning uh a set of videos to explain benefits to a particular company, do you take into account their corporate culture and does the the end product change? For example, if you're explaining benefits to a stodgy kind of Wall Street firm versus uh a startup such as yours, where you've got a bunch of millennials who are young and hip and um 85% of them, I think it was the last stat I saw, watch videos when they're on the internet or prefer videos for communication. Does the approach change? Do you take that into account?
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. For us specifically, we're always looking at what works for different employee demographics within different industries. Because exactly to your point, how we describe, you know, let's say a consumer-driven health plan to a Wall Street bank employee is gonna be significantly different than how we do that to a startup in Silicon Valley. And that's where you're gonna increase engagement levels is it's gotta speak to that audience. There are no two pieces of content that I think are identical. There may be some similar elements, but it's gotta resonate and really be custom to their culture.
DavidLet's follow up on that and kind of do a little bit of a deeper dive. Um, we've gone from a universe where just a few years ago, the biggest decision that an employee had to make was do I want the HMO or the PPO? Do I want the $500 deductible or the $1,000 deductible? Now we're in this kind of defined contribution, employee-defined benefit package world. Yep. Does that make communications such as this even more important? And how so?
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's a really great question. I think with healthcare reform, it's changed the game. But what it's also done is it's given employers an opportunity, especially if they're moving to a defined contribution plan, it's given them an opportunity to start the conversation around consumerism. Like it or not, healthcare reform is here. And part of it is really empowering an employee to really play a role in understanding how they can control costs and how they can take advantage of uh, quite frankly, the rich rewards that their employers are giving them. A really great example of that, uh, David, is so I worked for this large company for many years and they contributed $1,500 every single year to our HSA plan. They put that on the in the benefits guide. I had no idea. I went with the PPO because I felt that that was going to be the best solution for me. In five years, I went to the doctor maybe five times for my annual checkup. I'm now getting ready to have my first child. And had I known about the triple tax advantages and the fact that I could take those HSA dollars with me wherever I went, the child would be would be free for delivery, uh not forever. And that's something that I think of where we are today. If an employer can make that change and have employees understand that that's the kind of impact they can have on their life, man, for me personally, maybe that might have changed my mind on leaving the company. I can't say that for certain, but that's why it's important is employees need to start really getting in the driver's seat. And I think video is a really, really simple way to get them to understand that.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, MyEdge, the premier provider of Form 5500 prospecting solutions for benefit advisors. Do you want to find prospects in your area without having to make cold calls, but with a warmth reduction from a network relationship or the prospect's accounting firm? How about finding companies that are out of compliance on their Form 5500 filing? What if you could find prospects that are paying more than standard compensation for their products and services? MyEdge makes it easy to create a pipeline of only qualified leads, and you'll set yourself apart from the crowd when you know how to build a targeted value add strategy for companies you want to work with. Clients and prospects always appreciate it when their benefit advisors take the time to understand their employee benefits before they meet. Don't act and sound like everyone else. Use my edge and get the ultimate unfair advantage. To learn more about this innovative prospecting solution, visit our website at www.shift shapersonline.com. Generally speaking, for brokers, for benefit advisors if you prefer, does this help them compete? Does this help them differentiate themselves? Because we know we're now also in an environment where benefit advisors are moving some of them from a more product-oriented play to a value play. How does this help them?
SPEAKER_03So I think it's in a few different ways. You know, there are tools out there that are great. You can create stuff on your own, and then there's services. I think where I'm seeing at least a lot of traction is you think about you are a former benefits advisor, David. So you can probably relate a lot to this, is there's a lot of wasted time, whether it's traveling to open enrollment sessions, answering questions that were sort of answered already in those enrollment sessions, because people generally find it very difficult. Not to mention the single most important piece in all of this that tends to get overlooked are those decision makers at home. So for benefit advisors, as they're continuing to think, where are my sort of time and effort better spent? Is it going to 32 locations for one of their clients to do face-to-face enrollment sessions? Or is having a consistent message for every single employee and those decision makers at home more important? So what we find is that brokers and benefit advisors are partnering with GuideSpark because we do all of that heavy lifting. You know, we're a leader in this, and you know, we if people want to check more, learn more about GuideSpark, they can obviously do that on our website. But um change is coming. And I think the the days of the old model of here's a $50,000 video, and you know, it's gonna take eight months to deliver and it's gonna be stale, that model's done. And it's really got to be something innovative. If you look at consumer web trends, YouTube gets six billion views every single month. 80% of those views are on a mobile device. How many benefit advisors are enabling employees and decision makers at home to learn about the benefits that are gonna impact them every single day on the device that they're most connected to?
DavidAnd that's certainly part of the story. I wonder if there's more to the benefit advisor-employer conversation. So if I'm if I'm trying to gain a client, I'm talking to a qualified prospect, and I say, look, we utilize a better way to communicate with employees. Is it still enough that it's the cool new thing and it's very tantalizing in employers and HR departments like that? Or do you need to back, if you're an advisor, do you need to back that up with stats?
SPEAKER_03Great question. Um, video is not a cool new thing anymore. Video is here. And you know, it's funny, the biggest industry we serve is manufacturing, which you think would be the slowest adopters. So I think the stats are what's really important. What kind of impact, what kind of ROI is this going to show them? When when we're talking to brokers, it it always comes down to okay, do I spend $10,000 on print glossy benefit guides, or do I spend $10,000 on five videos where I can embed those printed resources and track who's actually reading the printed, who's engaging with content, where they're struggling with, so that the conversations I'm having as an employer are with the employees around things that are important to them. You can have that sort of two-way communication, and that's where benefit advisors can really start to add value is well, are we trying to increase adoption in a certain plan? Well, let's see if communications and change management can help lead to any sort of higher adoption rates in certain plans and voluntary benefits, um, things of that nature.
DavidOne of the things that I'm always asked in my practice, and I'd be interested in your take on it, is especially as my generation, the older generation, kind of ages out of these plans, and we're we're speaking to more and more to millennials, and we've done a few programs about millennials and how you manage them, how you market to them, et cetera. What's the average length that you strive for in Explainer Video? I mean, I saw a stat a couple of years ago, Forrester did that folks who shop on the internet spend about 18 seconds on a website, and if they can't find what they're looking for, they go off to a new website. Now, obviously, you can't explain any kind of benefit plan in 18 seconds, but what do you strive for? What's the time frame where you got their attention and then you start losing them?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that that's a good question. So it is official. People have a have an attention span less than goldfish. New York Times article, breaking news back in June of this year. But what we look at at videos and engagement, about four and a half minutes is that magic number where if the content is engaging, if there are pieces of sort of, you know, whether it's polls, surveys, gamification within content, you can go a little longer. But if you look at online, the average sort of view times for YouTube, four minutes and twenty seconds. On entertainment news sites, three and a half minutes. On news websites, it's five minutes. So I think what what we see is this trend of five minutes and less is all you've got. So how do you make the most significant impact in five minutes? And that's something that that's not easy.
DavidSo back to a question we touched on earlier, again, for that particular generation, because those are the folks who are insurance buyers today. Is there a particular kind of visual that seems to grab their attention more?
SPEAKER_03Quite honestly, not really. I think it's um dependent on each organization, and that's where custom beats generic every single day.
DavidWell, that's that's true. I mean, you custom has to be generic because you can't just do generic stuff anymore. There aren't there aren't such animals as generic plans. There are so many wrinkles. Again, going back to the conversation we had earlier about all the voluntary benefits and ancillary benefits, and even now, more and more non-insurance benefits being offered to employees, you pretty much have to go custom. So I certainly would agree with that. As we wrap up in the last couple of minutes that we have, Phil, what do you see in terms of the future of communications? Where do you see what we're doing today going in the next, in the near term and then in the longer term?
SPEAKER_03It's a great question. What I'm seeing is is a fundamental shift in how people approach communications. I think what's really what HR has struggled with, and this is what we're hearing from our clients, is really having that strategic seat at the executive table. And we're seeing more and more companies making investments in communications for change management, for introductions to new plans, more importantly, to measure where the dollars are being spent. What we see is, you know, mobile is the future. If you're not on mobile already, you need to start thinking about it because by 2020, so in the next six years, millennials are going to be the number one working population in all industries. If you talk to any millennial out there today, they'll probably either have the latest iPhone 6 or an Android, and it'll be a battle of which is better. So you have to hit people on the device that they're most connected to and with information when they want it. And that's where video is a great way to do it. You also have to incorporate meaningful face-to-face. Nothing's ever better than face-to-face. And I don't think video will ever completely replace that. But if you are going to do face-to-face, you need to make sure you're not wasting time and you're not taking production time away. So what we're seeing is the shift of people using video, things like gamification within content itself. And aspirationally, if there's a way to you know personalize content so that it feels like this is speaking to me, Phil Wilkins, that's going to be a game changer.
DavidAbsolutely. Well, Phil Wilkins, Director of Partner Development at Guidespark, Phil, thanks so much for taking time to chat with our audience today. We appreciate it.
SPEAKER_03Thank you so much, David. I really appreciate the time.
DavidFor more information about this episode or about any of our earlier episodes, and to learn how to subscribe on iTunes so you never miss an episode, go to our website, ShiftShapersonline.com. While you're on the site, leave a comment and register to be part of the Shapers community. You'll be the first to learn about upcoming specials, like exclusive webinars and content you can use to take your business to the next level. Again, thanks for joining us for today's episode. And remember, you have the power to shape the shifts in your business.