The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #23: Keeping Medical Care Between a Patient and Doctor - With Gustav & Eric Hoyer
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week we are speaking with Gustav and Eric Hoyer, brothers who have created a start up named after the ancient Roman physician Galen of Pergamon. Galen is a start-up organization whose goal is to empower individual consumers to find quality medical care within certain pricing restraints.
I invited Gustav and Eric to talk about how the shift in the delivery of healthcare (progressively less personal and compassionate), and how their model facilitates providers in granting substantial discounts to patients. Listen in to learn about this innovative way of healthcare delivery in the new environment of larger overall out-of-pocket costs.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- How a confusing and convoluted payment system with multiple players lent itself to a more simple, straightforward model for consumers.
- How it helps patients to price shop.
- What the range of price variation is in the marketplace today.
- The company’s plans to create a nationwide footprint.
- How benefit advisors have the price conversation with prospects and clients.
- How brokerages might benefit from Galen’s service.
As the market shifts to an environment with larger overall out-of-pocket costs, how does one company shape a new service that helps patients purchase medical care? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_01Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Saltzman.
DavidThis episode is sponsored by Care One Advocates. Navigating healthcare is complex. Care One Advocates provides personalized healthcare support to employers and their employees in an on-demand 24-7365 environment. To learn more about how Care One creates white labeled broker solutions that help you build your brand, go to our website at ShiftShapersonline.com. In today's episode of Shift Shapers, we're really, really pleased to have uh Gustav and Dr. Eric Hoyer, two brothers, who are co-founders of Galen. And Galen's a startup and they're just kind of in their initial launch phase, but we thought it would be interesting because it's such a different model and a different idea than anything that we've seen in the marketplace before, that it would be a really interesting conversation to have to bring it to you now while even some of their work is in the in the more formative stages, albeit the final formative stages. So, gentlemen, welcome to Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Good morning.
DavidGood morning. Would you guys talk about your backgrounds a little bit and uh kind of how you got to where you were the point that you are at today?
SPEAKER_02Well, I'll start with that. Uh this is Eric, and I'm a physician, and I've been practicing uh radiology for well around 20 years and and uh have seen healthcare really from the inside from a from a practicing standpoint and have really seen the changes, most notably in the last four or five years that have been brought on, and just have experienced this restlessness in healthcare. And uh it seems as as time has gone on that the solutions are becoming fewer, and uh the complexity and the difficulty of getting what I do as a physician, which is compassionate medical care delivered to a patient, is becoming more difficult. And um really just seeing this trend, and uh along with my brother, felt that it was time to think about ways that maybe we could get that trend working in another direction.
DavidAnd Gustav, what's your background, Ben?
SPEAKER_03My background is mostly in technology and have worked in a variety of large corporate settings. I have worked for software companies, have developed a lot of code, really where the technological hat, and for me, the way I came to this project with my brother was thinking that the the ease and simplicity and the convenience we enjoy because a modern mobile technology and computing technology, the internet and the web, would eventually manifest itself in this somewhat messy world of healthcare, and and felt very passionately that these tools empower consumers. And what was interesting is with my brother's background in mind, you really see the two keystones of what Galen is, is is a physician's perspective into the business and then a technologist's passion for creating empowering technologies.
DavidNow the shift you guys saw was in a very particular and quite interesting, at least to me, and I know to our audience will be a particular facet of the entire healthcare universe. Talk a little bit about that.
SPEAKER_02Well, as healthcare and all the changes have unfolded, the thing that has become, I think, apparent both to physicians but also to patients, and I would like Gustave elaborate more on that, but is that healthcare is occurring more and more at arm's length. What do I mean by that? Well, the delivery of healthcare, the product itself, even though it's amongst the most compassionate services as a society that we provide to one another, is becoming less and less personal. It's becoming less and less compassionate, less and less intimate because it's occurring at the arm's length. The arm's length is more and more of the regulatory challenges, more and more of the payment system challenges. I think both physicians and patients were feeling, are feeling more and more alienated, if you will, from the actual product, which should be very intimate and very personal. So as things are moving more and more into this sort of large conglomerate regulatory sort of uh direction, it seemed like what we really needed to do was revisit what is healthcare. You know, I think both of us agree that healthcare is something that occurs whether or not there's a society. It's that foundational, it's that basic of a human interaction. It's one of the very first things we did for each other in the civil society. And in that intimacy, that primary function, we should go back to that and start there and see if we can find a new way to deliver healthcare that really respects that relationship, that there's two people in a room that are working on a problem, and it's rooted in compassion and the freedom of both parties to interact and respect and listen without the interference of sort of the indifferent regulatory universe, if you will.
DavidSo let's hone in a little bit. Exactly what does Galen do? And then we'll talk a little bit about who your target market is.
SPEAKER_03So Galen is really an attempt to bring clarity to the problem of finding this medical care and having experienced various insurance arrangements and HSAs throughout my career, realizing that my ability to engage that decision, how do I connect with that provider, and how do I understand what sort of price implications and what are the constraints? Everything from provider networks to payment terms, all of that machinery being an impediment, being off-putting, and realizing that in every other avenue of our modern life, we expect the convenience of technology to help us navigate the marketplace. What is the price that I will pay? What are my options? How can I be empowered to make choices? From travel to consumer goods, you name it, every aspect of our commercial life is a huge availability of marketplace information. That seems to be really difficult to find in the medical care space. And so the heart of it is giving patients tools to find physicians, both price and to consider what their offerings are and make choices that they're empowered to choose physicians freely from those who will list in Galen, and then we also provide tools to providers to be the other half of that marketplace and incent them to have price clarity, to meet the patient, not through their specialty. Say you're a pulmonologist. Well, most folks wouldn't really know what a pulmonologist does, but they may know they have trouble breathing. And so we are also trying to put tools that allow patients to find the care they need in a way they can understand without navigating the vagaries of medical terminology, and then to know what those prices are. And we'll get into why that I think is increasingly relevant with all the changes in the insurance marketplaces, the increase of deductibles, the awareness of patients of price. These sorts of tools are going to have to be there to support an efficient marketplace that satisfies patient and provider.
DavidAnd who's your target market?
SPEAKER_03Right now we're focusing a lot on the uninsured, but they're a natural constituent. And these are folks who are cash buyers but may not even realize they can enter the marketplace. These are folks whose default channel of medical care may be the emergency room or never. And this is a notoriously difficult niche of patients. But as we have gone with a very natural, obvious constituency, we realize in fact our constituency is anybody with a deductible of any significance. If you are paying for a plan that's a $5,000 deductible, you're a cash buyer to that amount. And while professionals in the field understand that, many people who are insureds don't quite understand yet they really are effectively cash buyers for a large amount of routine health care. We're not focused on the chronically ill. We're very careful to say that those extremely high cost and long-term sorts of arrangements aren't appropriate for our service. But for someone who has a sore shoulder, someone who uh needs to get a they have a sore tummy and they need to get into a doctor, and they don't want to use the more costly channels, the deductible world, that high deductible world, these are cash buyers, and we're trying to bring optimization for them.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, Care One Advocates. A recent survey revealed that brokers spend just 38% of their time selling. How much more productive could you be if you had a partner who was always available when clients called your office asking questions about their plan? And what if that partner provided a more in-depth level of service? How is that possible? Care One's Broker Advantage is a coordinated resource for your healthcare clients and their employees. When they have a question, anything, from what is a deductible and how does it work or finding the right doctor, to complex pharmacy and medical issues, scheduling appointments, and even help with record transfers, Care One answers the call with your agency name and provides all the information with down home friendly service. Care One Advocates is committed to helping you to build your brand while increasing the value you bring to your clients. Care One does the work and you get the credit. To learn more about Care One's range of services and how you can generate a better customer experience, improved outcomes, and spend more time selling, go to our website, shiftshapersonline.com. I want to be clear, and I know it's something that you guys stress a lot. Is this health insurance?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and that's that's really a critical question. This is not health insurance by any means. And in fact, what we're doing is bringing medical care to a marketplace, making it visible and clear, and allowing patients to come view that marketplace, the offerings they're in, and make their own selection, and then they they are purchasing this medical care just as they would uh purchase uh, say, from a list of books on Amazon or or whatever service that they might do. It's really a free marketplace where the healthcare is purchased and it's purchased up front. And that's really one of the things that really is radically different about this. I think most people are aware that healthcare, the business as usual, the way things typically work, is always in one, two, three months in arrears, meaning it's it's three months down the road before that visit to the doctor is settled and goes through the insurance company. And oh, it turns out that you're in your deductible, so you actually owe that money, and now you're two months later and you're trying to sort out what it is you owed, you didn't realize you owed that much, and most of those challenges disappear. When patients are able to see up front what the price is, they know exactly from the get-go how much this visit is going to cost. By purchasing it right at that moment, they're getting tremendous price efficiency. All the complexity and the expense of figuring out the cost after the fact through the large insurance mechanism, all of that disappears. And it becomes the patient purchasing the medical care at the value of the care itself.
DavidWhen we talk about pricing, and I don't think most people are aware of this, what's added to the you go to a doctor, you have a procedure, whatever the particular code is, that has a price if you kind of decompartmentalize it. That that has a particular price. But by the time it goes through all the other pieces, there are costs added on. Cost of money, cost of waiting, all of those things. More or less, for the average listener to understand, how much is added on average to a particular code at a physician's office by the time it gets all the way through the insurance carrier mechanism?
SPEAKER_02And that's that's a great question because it's a wide range, but it's very substantial. And it really begins with the prices that are charged. Most third-party payers or insurance companies negotiate with doctor's offices for a certain price that that doctor's office will charge for a certain service. They do that up front, long before patients come and see the doctor. That's already agreed upon. And those prices are often negotiated sort of in a closed space, meaning one doctor doesn't know what another doctor's office is charging, so there's no comparison. They may not even know one insurance company doesn't know what another insurance company is paying. So it's all a very closed system, makes negotiating the prices at the outset very difficult. It's not a free market sort of a mechanism. Once that price is arrived at, in order for the physician's office to obtain that price or that that reimbursement, if you will, they have to take what they've done with the patient and break it down into codes, which are minute little fragments of work. And that's a very meticulous job that takes a lot of staff, a lot of resources at the office. That code then is submitted to the insurance company. It's sorted out what's paid by the patient, what's paid by insurance. The office then has to sort that difference out. They may have to go to the patient to collect some amount of money. That's then done, and very frequently patients by that time aren't aware that they're responsible for any amount, and so the offices then have to pursue that amount. And very typically, doctors' offices collect far less than 100% on the patient portion of the bill. And not infrequently, and unfortunately, many times that portion, the patient responsibility, winds up in three, four-month collection processes, and physician offices very frequently collect maybe 40-50% of the patient responsibility. All of that long, complicated process adds, I think I very conservatively would say, you know, 20% onto the bill based on how efficient an office is, how efficient an insurance company is, but there's many situations where it's even more than that. It might be 30 or 40%, particularly when you add in the fact that physicians' offices aren't paid typically, even by the insurance company, for two or three months after the service. That makes it a very costly sort of revenue stream because you're always several months behind as opposed to payment at the time of service.
DavidNow, I know that you guys are just in the launch phase, but where are you today in terms of geographic scope and what are the short, intermediate, and long-term goals?
SPEAKER_03We have launched in basically the Rocky Mountain West. We're working in Wyoming and Colorado right now and focusing on building that initial awareness here. As we start to roll out, we intend to go at a national scope, and we've been building a business infrastructure to support a national scope. We're looking to do as we roll out is first we have to engage the medical community and physicians and to bring them on. And even that has a bit of a training curve as physicians begin to understand the power of what they have in their hands and the sorts of efficiencies it brings so they can understand how to price and offer their services to the platform. So right now we're active in the Rocky Mountain West. Uh our intent is over the next year to roll out to some of the major metropolitan markets where there would be significant customers, and that would include some. So obviously, the populous states would be Texas, California, New York, Florida, the South. We're going to roll. We're also going to follow the interests. So we have a way of tracking everybody when they do a search. We don't know who they are or where they are. We just know where searches have occurred, and it's going to allow us to identify markets that are interested where there's a native interest and to move pretty aggressively to build a supporting set of offerings in that community. So we are carefully tuned to where the market's going to lead and we're poised to follow it.
DavidAnd for those people who might want to take a look at your website, it's Galen, G-A-L-E-N. And we'll have more information on the Shift Shapers website. Question in terms of distribution and channels. Are you currently, do you intend to be benefit advisor-friendly? Is that a community that you think would be a good partner with you guys?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, one of the things I think Gustav mentioned that originally this was conceived for the pure patient consumer, the self-pay patient. But one of the powers of a free market that we've come to realize is that I think there's tremendous value in the world of benefits and even for insurance payers. How might that look? Well, if you have a patient who has some level of benefit and there's some amount of a deductible that's at play in their benefits, say it's just a straight insurance policy or say the employer is managing some portion of that. What we're seeing is that in the Galen marketplace, healthcare, first of all, is easily seen. It's clear. You can compare doctors and their prices. And when patients do that, they select, by definition, the most efficient choices for them. And in so doing, they're able to obtain very measurable discounts, 20, 30, 40%. Again, it's hard to be specific because of the insurance contract prices. You don't know what the denominator is, but ultimately very substantial price efficiencies and discounts. And in so doing, for that $1,000 or $2,000 or $3,000 of managed deductible type money, patients are able to get far more medical care than they would if they just went down the road of the standard insurance contract prices that are in place. By having the free market, the prices are meant to be attractive to the patient. And in so doing, the providers, the healthcare physicians, their goal becomes not satisfying the insurance company that they did a certain amount of work, it's in satisfying the patient. That the patient paid this amount of money, the patient received that amount of care, they received this substantial discount, and it's a far more efficient way to proceed through that deductible portion or that cash buying portion of their benefit.
SPEAKER_03And one thing I'd add too about the brokerage side, and this comes from my experience having worked for large insurers, the administrative services or the self-insured employer will obviously benefit because they're paying out that. Another thing we can see have thought of that may be of interest to brokerages is another offering that's complementary to a high deductible plan an employer may choose. And so pairing with that and offering to employees in the insured group as part of the benefit offer some connection to Galen that those efficiencies would be actually passed down to the employees directly and exploring with employers, even if they reserve some of their money for that, there's some interesting possibilities, again, so that employer groups can take advantage of this price efficiency in combination with some of the other insurance products that may be going. So for a broker, it could be another tool in the bag, as they say, and a way to have some really compelling benefit features for employer groups as well.
DavidGentlemen, unfortunately, that's all the time we have for this episode. I sense that we could probably talk endlessly about what you're doing and where the market's going. And we'll visit again with you as you build out your model and as you get further launched into some more states. But Eric and Gustav, I want to thank you very much for sharing your story with the Shift Shapers podcast audience today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thanks, too.
DavidFor more information about this episode, or about any of our earlier episodes, and to learn how to subscribe on iTunes so you never miss an episode. Go to our website, ShiftShapersonline.com. While you're on the site, leave a comment and register to be part of the Shapers community. You'll be the first to learn about upcoming specials, like exclusive webinars and content you can use to take your business to the next level. Again, thanks for joining us for today's episode. And remember, you have the power to shape the shift in your business.