The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
Ep #22: It's All About Millennials - With Gerry Herbison
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of the ShiftShapers Podcast, we are very pleased to be speaking with Dr. Gerry Herbison. Gerry is the Director of the Chartered Leadership Fellow designation and Assistant Professor of Management at The American College.
I invited Gerry to talk about his expertise in the management of, by and for Millennials. Tune in to learn about the generations shift that is happening in the insurance and benefits world and how we can shape environments that attract and retain this group of people.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
- What is a Millennial?.
- What makes Millennials so different that we need to think about them as a separate, distinct cohort.
- What agencies need to do to attract this group.
- How the recruitment discussion need to change.
- How to create an environment where Millennials can flourish.
- How this cohort prefers to communicate (more or less) and if they like working alone or in groups.
As generations shift in the insurance and benefits world, how do we shape an environment that attracts and retains millennials? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
SPEAKER_00Change either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industries. Get ready to become the change that you want to see. Here's your host and chief transformation strategist, David Stoltzman.
DavidThis episode is sponsored by Care One Advocates. Navigating healthcare is complex. Care One Advocates provides personalized healthcare support to employers and their employees in an on-demand 24-7 365 environment. To learn more about how Care One creates white labeled broker solutions that help you build your brand, go to our website at ShiftShapersOnline.com. Today we're very pleased to be speaking with Dr. Jerry Herbison. Jerry is director of the Chartered Leadership Fellow designation and assistant professor of management at the American College. Good morning, Jerry.
SPEAKER_02Good morning. How are you?
DavidI'm well, thank you. Thanks for being on Shift Shapers and sharing some of your knowledge and your expertise with our audience today. First of all, um tell us a little bit about your background, because I think I don't want people to think that you just sprouted in academia.
SPEAKER_02And that's a very good point. I think from an academic standpoint, I'm a little bit like a unicorn. I uh started about 20 years ago in the industry with some uh sales experience before that, but I came in to the industry as a sales advisor, as a financial planner, uh earned my CHFC and CFP in the field, ended up uh managing a team of about 20, you know, recruiting, finding, developing about 20 advisors, and uh ended up uh having the opportunity to move to the American College about 10 years ago, and uh spent the first four years as a VP of sales working with our major client companies throughout the nation. And then about six years ago, I went through a master's program, was offered the opportunity to move over to the faculty, and then over the last four years, I uh completed my doctorate and uh have uh kind of continued to develop my uh breadth of academic knowledge, and I uh I run the CLF program. I teach in our Masters of Science and Financial Services program, I teach the practice management course there, I teach in our MSM Masters of Science and Management program, and I will be teaching in our doctoral program, the behavioral finance course.
DavidSpeaking of the kind of breadth of the things that you teach about, I'd like to hone in on one particular area today. One of the areas in which you have significant expertise is teaching and speaking about management of by and for millennials. To start that conversation, who is a millennial?
SPEAKER_02Essentially millennials, and and you can look in a a number of different sources, but loosely stated, it's basically anybody that was born between 1980 and and 2000.
DavidAnd we talk about them as a cohort, and and you hear people talk about millennials all the time. What makes them so different than everybody else?
SPEAKER_02Well, the millennials were uh brought up in a very different uh parenting style and a socialization style, and uh what was happening around them is very different than some of the cohorts before them, the uh you know, the Gen X, the people that were born between 1965 and uh and uh 1980, uh the baby boomers born between 64 and 46 and 64. The millennials were brought up by a group of people, the parents, that were much more concerned with the emotional well-being and connectivity of their children. And you see this in the fact that instead of just running over and playing with a friend, they had a play date. And the play date was screened before the uh the play date actually occurred. So they knew the parents, they knew if there were weapons in the house, they knew all of these kind of things. So they were a little bit more protected. Now, what that does mean is that they're very comfortable communicating with people of multiple generations because they were much more interactive with their parents, they're much more interactive with their teachers, they're much more interactive with adults. So what they are expecting from a communication standpoint is is very different. If for nothing else, the frequency. I mean, when you know you were in the business for years, I was in the business. When we first started in the business, we'd probably be happy if we were communicated with by our manager once a week, once a day at most. Well, this is a group of people that are very comfortable with five and ten touches from per day from their supervisor. And in fact, if they don't get that, they start thinking there might be something wrong.
DavidSo beyond the communication aspect, I know you know an awful lot of agencies around the country are dealing with the fact that principals and some of their key people are aging out. Um, there are a lot of us boomers who are kind of heading off into the sunset or certainly cutting back our work schedules. If I'm an agency, uh, let's say I'm an old line agency, what do I need to do? And this is kind of a two-part question. First, in order to attract millennials and then to create an environment where they can feel comfortable and be successful.
SPEAKER_02And that's a great question. It's a question that all of these companies are looking at right now because again, the average manager and the average producer in our industry is a 54-year-old white man. And we're looking to expand on the diversity. So I think the first thing to say is something that's a little bit bigger than just bringing in millennials is bringing in any group that isn't basically white men. You have to make a concerted effort. You have to choose and then create systems to support whatever group you are intending to bring in. And you need to make the whatever the group that is feel comfortable. So having business lunches at Hooters might not be your best bet when bringing in any kind of new group. So when you're looking at this kind of intentionality, especially around millennials, what you're really looking at is, again, a differential in the way you're uh you're talking to them during the recruiting process, the way that you're communicating with them at the beginning, again, the amount of connectivity, the way that you end up building teams. I mean, our industry has been built on cowboys, people that could survive on their own, not by themselves. And this is a group of people that is much more comfortable and desires the connectivity of working with teams rather than entirely on their own. And then ultimately, on the long end, when you are looking to move them into leadership positions, supporting them in a way that is a little bit higher touch and uh much more of a mentorship process than was done in the past. So I can talk about any one of those pieces if you'd like.
DavidWell, let's let's zone in on the very beginning part of the process. He's one of the things you just said is that you need to talk to them in the recruiting process differently than you might have done before. Talk about those differences and and what that conversation might sound like if you wanted to resonate with a millennial that you were looking to bring into your agency.
SPEAKER_02And and this is one of my favorite topics around the millennials, and it goes to the kind of, and I'm gonna use it the term a little loosely, the insanity of the way we look at this generation as disloyal, as people who are not loyal to their organization. So painting the picture, we fired their parents, we fired their aunts and uncles, we fired their cousins, and then we ask them to be loyal. So we're giving them this message that the workplace is not safe from a longitudinal standpoint, but then we expect them to be loyal. Well, what that means is when you are in your recruiting discussions with a millennial, they might want to be in an organization for a significant period of time. But the real challenge is they don't believe it's possible. They don't believe that you can be in an organization for five, ten, fifteen, twenty years. So whereas when you and I were brought into the industry, we talked about this long-term opportunity, years and years and years. What we have to talk to this group now about because when we tell millennials that they can have a 15 or 20 or 50-year career, they want to believe it, but they don't. They think we're lying to them. So what we have to talk to them about is the control that they have and the options that they have after they come into the career and the fact that they own the process as opposed to what they're hearing from all their friends where you can come in and be there in an organization for a period of time and then let go willy-nilly. So the big discussion change is we talk to them not about longevity, but about control.
DavidInteresting. So once you've had that conversation and you've attracted someone in this group to become a part of your agency, what environmental changes need to happen and what's the thought process in senior management and others to keep them there and to help them flourish?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think that the the first thing is the fact that when you're talking about a cohort, let me take a step back to somewhere between this conversation and the last one, is when you're talking about a cohort, you're talking about central tendencies. You have this kind of bell curve effect where 70% of the people have very, very similar tendencies. Well, this is a huge cohort. It's about 75 million people. And what we're trying to always do is bring the best of the group in and we like we've always been doing. We've always wanted the best of every cohort that's available. So even though we're we're talking about these tendencies for communication and preference for working for teams, you're always going to be looking for the people that are most entrepreneurial, most coach, you know, at the same time being coachable. So when you do get them in, I think that the one of the big issues is understanding them and not talking to them as if they created their own preferences for communication, for teaming by themselves. Because I think what you have, and I hear a lot of people in the field talk like this, you know, because I deal largely with field leaders. It's this, you know, you kids, you you people that are are younger that I don't understand, and that's what they're hearing. And you get this instant barrier. So the first thing you have to do is be very inclusive about your discussion. Talk to them as adults. They are adults. If you've chosen to bring them in, they're adults. Accept the fact that they are looking to communicate in a specific way, and then over time they will develop their own methods and forms of communication that will probably pull back a little bit. So they're communicating with their peers as opposed to communicating with you. So again, I think the the first thing is drop the blame, change the way that you're communicating, create the opportunity for them to work in teams. That's a that's a huge issue where you have people that, you know, you have one group that is acknowledged to be better at marketing, and another group that's acknowledged to be better at case preparation and sales and all of those different kinds of things. So allow for it to happen, create the mechanisms and don't fight it. The big problem is you still have these 55-year-old white guys digging their heels in saying, this is the way I was brought into the industry, and darn it, this is how they're going to be brought in. That will never work.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, Care One Advocates. A recent survey revealed that brokers spend just 38% of their time selling. How much more productive could you be if you had a partner who was always available when clients called your office asking questions about their plan? And what if that partner provided a more in-depth level of service? How is that possible? Care One's Broker Advantage is a coordinated resource for your healthcare clients and their employees. When they have a question, anything, from what is a deductible and how does it work or finding the right doctor, to complex pharmacy and medical issues, scheduling appointments, and even help with record transfers, Care One answers the call with your agency name and provides all the information with down home friendly service. Care One Advocates is committed to helping you to build your brand while increasing the value you bring to your clients. Care One does the work and you get the credit. To learn more about Care One's range of services and how you can generate a better customer experience, improved outcomes, and spend more time selling, go to our website, shiftshapersonline.com. Is the education process for this group different? Is the approach, does the approach need to be different in educating these folks once they come into the agency in terms of product sales techniques, all of the basket of skills that they need to be successful?
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. And that's one thing that the American College has really changed is acknowledging this education process as going in a very different direction. This is a group of people that are used to getting their information in much smaller chunks. So whereas in the past we might have a 30 to 50 minute video, now the e-learning modules tend to be much shorter, 15, 20 minutes. And if it is a longer program, we will chunk it up. So the length of the educational interventions, if you will, are much shorter. The fact is they really, really like examples. This is a group of people that has learned through case studies. And, you know, the Harvard model has trickled down into undergraduate education. So in the past, people were just expected to memorize, learn things that they were told to learn. Now it's much more experiential. It's a lot of group work. It's looking at cases, it's analyzing things. So what we're trying to do in the creation of our programs is acknowledge that fact and be much more in, you know, the American College has got has two new courses that are entirely applications-based, as opposed to just kind of the delivery of here's what the tax code is.
DavidSo that's the educational process. Let's go kind of to the other end of their initial tenure with a with an agency and maybe in a new position. How do they react to sales goals? How do you talk with them about sales goals in a way that incentivizes them rather than turns them off?
SPEAKER_02I think it's a good question, but the reality is that the people that we bring in, this is a differential that I don't think is all that clear. Because people that are going to succeed in our business have a certain amount of resiliency. They have a certain amount of self-drive. That really hasn't changed. I think the big difference is in the frequency of the communication that you're having with them about their goals, about their expectations. Whereas, again, you and I, you know, just talk to me once a week about something. This is a group of people that you can check in with on a much more frequent basis. So I think that overall, the the what the messaging really is is here's the expectations, here's how we're going to support you, here are what you're here are the resources that we have for you, and here's what you're supposed to be doing on a day-to-day basis. That really hasn't changed all that much, but the frequency that we talk to them about it has has changed pretty dramatically.
DavidAre they more sensitive to, for lack of a better phrase, the agency having a sense of community than previous groups might have been?
SPEAKER_02Meaning, are they looking for more community? Absolutely. This industry has always been pretty high on community. I mean, you hear about the great agencies, the agency managers having the big cookouts and things like that. But now it's much more on a frequent basis. And instead of having, you know, five people working all five independently, what you'll find is these teams that are built around community. So they will, you know, there are companies that will do events. And instead of having one person rent the booth, they'll have five people out there working together and they'll share all of the leads that come out of it. So the difference is, again, instead of the individual cowboy that might like the community on a social basis, now we're trying to create community in the business practices.
DavidOne of the things that I know you teach about and you talk a lot about, and let's talk about it maybe too early, but let's talk about it in terms of this cohort. You talk about moving from management to leadership. How's that applicable to this group? Is it different than it used to be in the things that we used to look for as agency leaders when we were identifying potential leaders and helping to groom them and bring them along?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think the one big thing about this group is because they are so connected, they're so interconnected with each other, I think we're probably going to, once we get over the hump of bringing more younger people in, people under the age of 30, I think they're going to be, quite honestly, better leaders. Because what you're looking at in the distinction between management and leadership, management is very task-focused. Leadership is about looking over the horizon, creating the culture, creating the strategy. And it requires a very high level of interaction. You want to have followers that are voluntary, that are willing to follow you into the trenches. Because this is a group of people that has worked in cohorts, that has worked in groups all the way through their education period. And if we socialize them in this uh this business model where they're working in groups rather than individually, I think that the people that rise up out of that are going to be better at creating the community because that's what their followers are going to be looking for. So instead of saying, well, I'm doing this because I have to, I'm doing this because this is how I lead. This is the way I believe. This is my DNA is much more inclusive.
DavidGenerally speaking, are is it a group that's more amenable to creating strategic partnerships? I mean, I know for a long time the model for agencies was build a mode around it, you know, we're our own island, we can do everything. Is this a group that, because they're so social, might be more um adept at and more interested in creating strategic partnerships with other firms?
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. I mean, if you look at the way that this group communicates, and let's take it outside of our industry, one of the things that successful organizations do is they tap into the fact that this is a group of people that has very vast networks and they have access to information in real time that I certainly didn't have when I was 25. I didn't have the big network, I didn't have the ability to communicate with them in real time now. It's very easy to do that. So I think that this millennial generation is really attuned to creating these micro networks that will come and go as needed. So hopefully some of them will be kind of more long-term. But I think this is really the way they think. They are always thinking about networking. They're always thinking about what link can I create. I mean, in reality, that's one of the concerns, just like communications is a concern. This is a group of people that technology is part of their DNA, that communication is part of their DNA. And some of the rules that we have in our industry, because of licensing and commission sharing and all those kind of things, there are some, I don't want to say drawbacks, but the way our business works doesn't match up with the way that they've developed their communication style.
DavidIn the minute or so that we have left, if we kind of fast forward 10 or 15 years and the millennials are large and in charge, and they've they've made some shifts and shapes of their own, well, how does the industry look different, at least at the agency level? What do you foresee in terms of what that might look like then rather than now?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think that our past, our industry's past is we build it based on what we think is the best thing for the company, what we think the clients might buy. And those things tend to sync up. And it was, you know, the there were limited distribution sources for clients to find the products that serve their needs. I think what's going to happen is both the companies are going to be much more flexible in creating solutions for clients. But really the big difference, and it will be all driven from the field, is that again, the millennials are very acutely aware of consumer focus. What does the consumer want? Because you know, you have all of this mass customization, if you will. And I think what you're going to find is a very, very consumer-centric organization in the field that is much more flexible, much less likely to say we can't do that, and look for solutions. So the companies are going to have to be more flexible, the operational systems are going to have to be more flexible, and how that's going to change the legislative and the regulatory bodies, I don't know. But I think that that's really where it's going because everything else is going in that direction.
DavidThe future is always a great place to wrap up an interview. Jerry, thank you so much for sharing your expertise and your insight with the Shift Shapers audience. We've enjoyed talking to you. Thanks for having me. For more information about this episode or about any of our earlier episodes, and to learn how to subscribe on iTunes so you never miss an episode. Go to our website, ShiftShapersOnline.com. While you're on the site, leave a comment and register to be part of the Shapers community. You'll be the first to learn about upcoming specials, like exclusive webinars and content you can use to take your business to the next level. Again, thanks for joining us for today's episode. And remember, you have the power to shape the shifts in your business.