The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
EP #435: Just Forget It - and Start Over! — With Wally Gomaa
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this week's episode, Simple Pay Health co-founder Wally Gomaa discusses the main difficulties facing the health insurance industry. He sees a lack of transparency and complexity, but he also sees stakeholders working to develop a better healthcare model.
Contrary to popular belief, he does not think that the healthcare system is broken; rather, he believes that it was not created with the needs of consumers in mind. With a focus on simplicity and transparency for all stakeholders, including patients, providers, and plan sponsors, Simple Pay Health seeks to make healthcare and health insurance operate more like other industries.
What You’ll Learn From This Episode:
1:38 Cost and complexity being the two primary challenges in the health insurance space.
3:39 Who benefits from the current system, exactly?
8:15 Empowering patients by giving them the freedom to select where they receive care.
10:08 Implementation of the Simple Pay Health Model in stages.
13:41 How does the new model affect overall claim spending?
15:50 Building a Network for Simple Pay Health: Partnerships and Optimization
Enjoy The Show?
- Don't miss an episode, subscribe via iTunes, Stitcher or RSS.
- Leave us a review in iTunes (here's how)
- Join the conversation by leaving a comment below!
What if magically you could just forget everything that you think you know or that you do know about today's health insurance arrangements and the entire system? And you could start over with a clean sheet of paper and a well-inked pen and design it from the ground up. We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either paralyzes or energizes. The choice is yours. You're listening to the Shift Shapers Podcast. You're about to learn firsthand from businesses and entrepreneurs who have successfully shaped the shifts in their industry. Get ready to become the change you want to see.
DavidThis episode is brought to you by Triumph Technologies, creator of the market-leading benefits connector Ben Admin software. Now with special pricing for smaller groups. To learn more, call Carol Motstick at 336-253-5722. That's 336-253-5722. Let Triune help you get out of the admin business and back into the selling business.
AnnouncerAnd now, here's your host, Story Brand Certified Guide and Chief Transformation Strategist, a Chip Shaper strategies, David Saltzman.
DavidAnd to help us answer today's question, we've invited Wally Goma, who is co-founder of Simple Pay Health. Welcome, Wally. Thanks for joining us. Hey, thank you for having me today. Now give us a quick background about your path. How did you get to be doing what you're doing?
SPEAKER_02You know, it's been a uh it's been sort of a popery uh background in the healthcare industry, 30 years in healthcare, started on the provider side of the industry in finance, defected to the other side of the fence and worked on the carrier side, was president for one of the national insurance carriers, worked as a benefit consultant for a number of years before really leading a number of businesses in the point solution space.
DavidSo let's level set for the audience. What's the problem? And everything is not the appropriate answer.
SPEAKER_02Well, I'll just say cost and complexity. If we if I were going to categorize the challenges in the employer-sponsored health insurance space, you know, we look at it as cost, it's complexity. When we meet with plan sponsors, those are always the two items that sort of come to the surface. One sometimes maybe is a little, you know, more painful to them than others, but we always frame it around those are the two primary challenges we're we're working to solve for. And we're really looking to try to bring savings and simplicity to those two elements.
DavidDoes cost drive complexity or does complexity drive cost?
SPEAKER_02Yes. You know, I got you got your one-word answering. That's right. No, I think our our belief, you know, really, and it's been validated over the last several years, is that the complexity in healthcare, in health insurance, really is preventing us as Americans to behave the way consumers behave in the real world. If you think about the complexity of the plan design and the payment model, only about 4% of plan participants, if you give them the plan design terms of deductible co-insurance, co-pay, and out-of-pocket maximum, can match that term to the definition. And then, you know, you never really know what anything's going to cost before you go. I would argue, you really don't know what anything's going to cost even after the fact when you get all those many bills and EOBs that we have to spread across the kitchen table. And we really wanted to try to eliminate, you know, most of that so that health insurance and healthcare would work the way it does when you buy anything else in the real world.
DavidNot to be too terribly sinister, but at the base, do you think that there are folks profiting from the system who really don't want consumers to understand what the hell's going on?
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, whether it's intentional or not as it relates to complexity and lack of transparency, you know, depending on which stakeholder group you're pointing to, certainly, you know, there's some level of status quo, pays really, really well. I think many would would like to not see changes. But, you know, I would say on the whole, when we work with, you know, plan sponsors, providers, patients, there are many that recognize we've got to be better. And those that are leaning in towards transformation that's good for all major stakeholders, incl you know, especially the patient who we're all here to serve. You know, I think those are those organizations that are sort of pulling away from everyone else, you know, and uh and leaning into creating a better model that is long overdue for the industry.
DavidWhen people tell me that they think healthcare is broken, I think my answer is no, it's it's not broken. It's working the way it was designed. It just wasn't really designed for consumers. Is that where you start, where you try to make it consumer-centric rather than payer-centric or provider-centric or or whatever? Or is it is it kind of like a Venn diagram where those pieces have to be carefully re-overlapped?
SPEAKER_02You know, as I sort of think about the industry, everyone has always tried to bring innovation forward, but it lands it ends up resulting with winners and losers. Everyone's playing this game of musical chairs to make sure they get a seat and they don't get knocked out of the equation. And when we designed the simple pay health model, we really wanted to take a different point of view. We wanted something that would be a win for all of the stakeholders so that patients would get a simpler experience and ultimately get better quality care, where providers could focus on practicing medicine and get them out of many of the administrative things that today are in the middle of that they're actually not very good at. And then finally, let's make sure that this is a win for the true payer in healthcare, the plan sponsor, you know, that's really funding, you know, healthcare for, you know, approximately 150 million Americans. And we wanted something that would result in a better experience and really better affordability for plan sponsors as well. And I think our success, you know, you know, while we're early, has really been around creating a better model, like you said earlier, starting from the beginning that would be a better approach for all.
DavidSo I mean it's it's a big order. It's like eating an elephant, and obviously you have to do it one bite at a time. Where do you guys start?
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, I'll tell you, I sometimes want to admit when we designed the model, we really didn't invent anything. We just made healthcare and health insurance as much as possible work the way it does when you buy things in the real world. So if you think about health insurance in today's world, you know, there's the confusing plan design terms in the payment model. There's really a lack of transparency on price and quality. We replaced it with a model where a plan participant would always know their cost ahead of time to the penny for every covered service, where there are no more bills or ELBs. Providers are actually paid in full when they submit their claim to the insurance company, the network discount is applied, providers are paid in full. And instead of the many bills and EOBs, members get one statement. The price that they're responsible for on that single monthly statement will be the price they expected to see earlier. They even have the ability to pay over time with 0% financing. So if you think about buying something in the real world, you know the price, maybe you know information on quality, you pay with your card, you swipe it, you pay later on a monthly statement. That's effectively what we've done. But at the heart of the program is that we don't set lower prices, we align the patient's out-of-pocket price as a fixed amount that aligns around quality. So your prices will be lower when you go to higher quality providers because, as we all know, better quality, you know, is more efficient and results in lower spend.
DavidYou know, you you started talking about folks understanding what something costs. And you alluded to that Kaiser Family Foundation study that comes out every year, and those of us in the industry look at it and we just shake our heads at the lack of healthcare literacy in the country. So if I'm one of your members and my doctor says, okay, you need a hip replacement, what's my process? What do I do that looks different than what I'm doing maybe in my previous plan?
SPEAKER_02So I would look at a hip replacement as an opportunity to empower the individual so that when they start down their clinical pathway as directed by their doctor, they're empowered with the tools and they have the freedom to choose where they want to go. So we're not narrowing networks, you know, we're not trying to steer somebody to go here versus there. We're not even trying to shame them, you know, into going here versus there. What we're doing instead is we're giving the patient easy access to information around their price out of pocket. They don't really care what the contracted rate is between providers and insurers. As you know, human beings, we just want to know what does it cost me? We give them their price, we give them information on quality that's drawn from one of the country's largest claiming quality data sets. We give them credible information that anybody can understand. So now somebody has information on their price, they have information on quality, and we say, you have the freedom to choose to go wherever you want to go. Our experience has been that when we give somebody not price transparency, but price certainty, they end up behaving the way consumers do in the real world. And this belief that, well, I people just go where their doctors tell them to is actually not true, but only when we create a model that works like buying everything else. If you think about it in the consumer world, advertising works really hard to try to get us to go here versus there. But as consumers, we rise up and we make an informed decision when we're buying other things in life. And that's exactly what we've done with healthcare.
DavidAnd now a word from our sponsor, Triune Technologies. As a salesperson or an agency leader, your most valuable commodity is time. That's why it's critically important that your benefits administration doesn't sneakily eat up time that you could be using to build your book or grow your agency. If you or your team is still doing case setup, working on creating and managing EDI feeds and dealing with ACA reporting, it may be time to look for a better tool. Benefit Connector is a done-for-use solution that understands your needs because it was created by benefits professionals just like you. For over 20 years, the system and its amazingly mature business rules have been honed to accept any type of group parameters and to keep you out there selling. Now, with special pricing for smaller groups, let Triune help you to get out of the admin business and focus on what you do best. Call Carol Motznik at 336-253-5722. That's 336-253-5722. And now, back to our interview. At a more granular level, as a member, do I have a dashboard or some interface where, okay, I come back from the doctor or you know, I've talked to my spouse and said, hey, dog on it, I need a hip replacement. How do I find all that information? Because part of the challenge that a lot of people have had is I've got to go to this site to look for that, and I've got to go to that site to look for that. And then how do I understand the difference between price and quality, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera? What's the mechanism that you guys provide that makes me as a consumer able to easily access and correlate that information?
SPEAKER_02David, before this session together, I needed to get a headset so that I could sound hopefully a little clear on this interview. What was the first thing I did? I went right to my smartphone, and within two seconds, I'm on Amazon and I'm looking at different options for my purchase as a consumer. We have effectively made health insurance and healthcare work just like that. We provide patients with a dedicated app that allows them within seconds to be able to evaluate the different providers available to them nationally. Again, we're not reducing choice. We're not, you know, we're not creating the traditional tiered networks and stack networks. We're just empowering individuals and giving them a chance to go. And I think the evidence has been that when we create something that is simple as going to your smartphone, individuals will, in fact, look before they go. And it's human behavior that we want to go to the best, especially when we see ahead of time that going to the best will translate to a lower out-of-pocket cost that is certain because we are using a plan model that has no more deductibles or coinsurance. We're using price tags for everything. Basically, it's a low, medium, and high copay plan up to an out-of-pocket maximum. But the difference between healthcare and buying a consumer electronic is it's way more personal. So we actually combine technology self-service, like in an Amazon-like shopping experience, with a consumer concierge, basically a personal shopper that we call our health pros. And those health pros, those health valets, are trained healthcare consultants that can help you essentially be a personal shopper, including scheduling your appointment to high-quality providers. And our experience, again, when I talk about our engagement rates in a moment, you know, really exceeded what we believed was possible when we were designing the model.
DavidSo we've talked a lot about the member perspective. But at the end of the day, if I'm a plan, what do I want to what do I want to know? I want to know what's my spend. What's my claim spend going to be? How does this kind of a new model affect overall claim spend?
SPEAKER_02So when you think about providers that perform at the highest level of quality, and quality is a big word for, and it's a big catchword for a lot of things. We're looking at are they practicing medicine consistent with clinical guidelines? Are they efficient? We have a measure we call the Goldilocks effect. You know, too much utilization is wasteful, too little things get missed, there's an amount of care that's just right. When we look at not just how does a provider, a doctor, perform in their practice of medicine, but who do they refer to downstream? And where do those providers admit their patients? Healthcare is a team sport. When we measure hospitals, not at the in the aggregate, no hospital is great at everything. We're measuring at the individual service line level. You know, hospital may over here may be best at cardiology, but not the place to go for orthopedics. When we put all of that together, patients that go to higher quality providers, they translate to about $5,000 in lower health care spend per patient per year. Not because they are cheaper in their reimbursement rates. We look at that also, but it's because they're higher quality, efficiency, outcomes, unit costs, readmissions. They have fewer never events, you know, never leave a surgical instrument in a patient. Like that's a real thing that we track. So when you put that all together, plan sponsors are super motivated to let's motivate our employees to go over to these top providers because we know it won't only translate to a lower copay to the member, the plan participant, it will also translate to lower claim spend that's going to affect their overall experience.
DavidNow, did you guys go out and build your own network so that the docs and the facilities understand the nuances of how you engage and how you pay?
SPEAKER_02I can't even imagine the undertaking that would have been. And honestly, I don't think we would have been successful if we wanted to go out and try to recreate. You know, so we're really partnered to make this available on a national level with a BUCA. We partner in almost all states around the country with Aetna. That allows us to have a national uh network to access. And we're not just renting a network, we're really partnered closely with them, you know, to optimize their national proprietary networks, the same networks they run, their fully insured business on. And uh, you know, that really allows us to be able to scale this instantly on a national level, regardless of where the employer and the employees reside. And we really have partnered with Maritane, their wholly owned TPA under the family of companies that is CVS Health to help us in this unique payment model, which is really unlike anything else that we've seen in the industry.
DavidYou mentioned engagement a while back, and of course, engagement is key because if you have a better mousetrap, but people don't use it, then it's not really a better mousetrap. It's kind of like Schrodinger's cat. I guess the the question is how do you educate all of the constituencies to understand this new model and how it works and why it's better for them and take them in whatever order you want, whether it's facilities or docs or patients or employers?
SPEAKER_02Well, I would also say if our goal was to try to educate and herd the cats to go in a certain direction, we would also have not have been successful. Instead, we just want to change the model so that individuals naturally perform the way they do without even having to think about it. So it's easy for the member, right? The play and participant. Here's your price for every covered service. Here's information on quality, go where you want to go. Just remember you're gonna get a monthly statement, and whatever your decision is is going to be reflected in your financial responsibility a month later. So it's very natural to the member. I like to say nobody has to go to open enrollment to be a good consumer of buying things in the real world. We shouldn't have made healthcare so complicated that somebody has to go to an open enrollment meeting. We just want to make healthcare work the way it does when you buy anything else. For providers, we also don't want to have to go and educate them, well, this insurance model is going to work differently. Instead, we just change the way claims are adjudicated. Providers get an ID card from a member, they verify benefits, they'll see that the member actually has no out-of-pocket responsibility that they have to collect. Why our industry does that is beyond me, that we make the seller, the provider, collect some of what's due to them from the member and the rest from the insurance company. Now they just verify benefits, submit their claim, the Aetna network discount is applied, and the provider is paid their contracted rate in full. And they're out of billing collection in bad debt. We aggregate claims once a month, we send a monthly statement to the member. And what's really cool here is we've eliminated the surprises. So if I chose a provider, I knew this was the copay I was going to be responsible for. I actually get a monthly statement that copay matches. So we combine price certainty on the front end with financial responsibility that is consistent on the back end. And the member even has the ability that when they get their monthly statement, they can choose to pay the balance in full or pay the minimum amount due and revolve that balance over time with a 0% line of credit that is automatically part of their benefits. And David, what we're really working to solve for here is we know that after college student loans, healthcare is the second largest category of consumer debt in the country. You know, on a good day, we're paying for those out-of-pocket costs with high interest rate credit card financing that just got a whole lot higher this year with interest rates doing what they're doing. Unfortunately, for many American families, they actually have to make choices of either having needed health care or paying their mortgage this month. So we wanted to embed into the model for the first time a true financial well-being benefit that allows people to pay over time and they don't have to go out and scramble for how they're going to be able to afford it. So having that 0% line of credit that's just part of your insurance, it doesn't require a credit check. It's just what you get as you enroll in your employer health plan has been really a very positively received element in our model.
DavidWell, and and long term, as we kind of wrap up here, long term, affording people the ability to get early care may be one of the biggest cost savers in the entire equation because uh too all too often we have folks who are functionally uninsured. They have a card in their pocket, but they can't afford to actually out of pocket what they need to to even get initial care. And we end up seeing junior, you know, with pneumonia in ICU for five days when they could have been treated with some broad spectrum antibiotics on day one or day two or day three and never had that 40 or 60 or $80,000 claim. So it's past due. Um Wally, we hope you'll come back and chat with us as the model grows and as things expand down the road. Wally Goma, co-founder of Simple Pay Health. Wally, thanks so much for sharing an exciting new model with the audience. Thank you for having me, David.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.