The ShiftShapers Podcast
Change either paralyzes or energizes - the choice is yours. Hear from businesses and entrepreneurs who have become energized and who have profited by shaping the shifts in their markets and practices. Become a SHIFTSHAPERS INSIDER and get our latest download, advance notice of all podcasts, podcast summaries, and special INSIDER-ONLY content. INSIDER SIGN UP
The ShiftShapers Podcast
EP 562 The Gen Z Retention Paradox - with Adele Webb
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
We unpack why so many Gen Z healthcare workers say they will look for a new role even while they crave long-term security and loyalty. We break down what “mobility” really means at the bedside, why trust is so low, and how education benefits can become a real retention strategy instead of a forgotten perk.
• Gen Z intent to job search versus desire for stability and security
• Mobility defined as internal growth, lateral moves, new skills and clearer pathways
• Trust gap driven by weak communication and low awareness of existing benefits
• What managers can do in weeks to make growth support believable
• Budget and priorities as barriers to comprehensive workforce education programs
• Three types of learning: continuing education, cross-training, higher education
• Keeping experienced nurses engaged while rebuilding the workforce pipeline
• Why many clinicians feel cautious about AI and what it can realistically augment
• What to invest in first and how to measure impact through retention and satisfaction surveys
"The Checklist Manifesto" by Atul Gawande
Click HERE
Cold Open And Show Setup
DavidWhat if the workers most likely to leave are also the ones who most want a stable career? We'll find out on this episode of Shift Shapers.
AnnouncerChange either energizes or paralyzes. The choice is yours. This is the Shift Shapers Podcast, bringing the employee benefits industry interviews with individuals and companies who are shaping the industry's shifts. And now, here's your host, David Saltzman.
DavidAnd our
Gen Z Job Search Numbers
Davidguest today is Adele Webb, Healthcare Workforce Advisor for Workforce Edge. Adele spent more than 42 years as a nurse and an educator. She's joining us today to unpack the 2026 Healthcare Workforce Barometer, a Harris poll survey of healthcare workers and employers. Welcome to Shift Shapers, Adele.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. I'm very honored to be here.
DavidIt's our pleasure. And let's dive right in. The survey says 70% of Gen Z healthcare workers expect to look for a new role in the next year. When you saw that number, what did it tell you?
SPEAKER_01It told me that very little has changed because when we looked at it the year before, it was almost the same percent. They're really searching for that place that they can trust to support them. And so I wasn't surprised by that number at all.
DavidDoes looking for a role mean they decided to leave or just that they're testing whether another employer offers what for them is a clearer future?
SPEAKER_01I think it might be both. Well, you need to see what's out there based on what you have at your current institution. And so I think it's testing the waters a little bit.
Mobility Without Leaving The Employer
DavidThat's interesting because the headline I think becomes even more interesting when we ask these workers what they actually want. And number one was mobility and stability, which seems like an oxymoron. 65% of Gen Z respondents expected to stay with one employer for five years or more, and 95% value long-term security. How do you reconcile those two numbers? Because it's a pretty wide gap.
SPEAKER_01And I think when you think about mobility, you're not necessarily thinking about changing organizations. You're thinking about upward mobility or even lateral mobility. So the opportunities to expand your career in a way, say move from ER to being in surgery or becoming a leader. So that's when I think about mobility. That's what I think about.
DavidThat's interesting. What would persuade a younger worker that staying put is the better career move?
SPEAKER_01I think they need to trust that there's opportunities for them. I have actually six grandchildren that are Gen Z nurses. I'm very proud of that. And I see their willingness to stay if they have an opportunity to grow. And so I have a grandson who got his dream job. He said, I'll never leave this place. This is perfect for me. I love it. He's looking for a job because he wanted to get certified in his area and they don't provide any benefit for that. And so it's disappointing when they want to be loyal and they want to stay, but they're not getting the things they need to grow in their career.
DavidSo the the question shifts from one of what might be loyalty in some cases to whether a career path is visible to them today.
SPEAKER_01And I think that's part of it. When you say visible, I don't know if you're asking if they know if it's available and they know about it. But one of the things that we saw is that even though I think over 70% of employers offer opportunities, less than 50% of them knew about it. And so there's a disconnect there in communication. And I think the onus really is on both of them. One, the employee needs to say, What do you have? What can you offer me? But the employer needs to get it out there. These are our benefits, and encourage people to take advantage.
DavidThere's 89% of Gen Z workers in general say that opportunities for advancement matter compared to 80% of all healthcare workers. So it's an interesting little difference there, but it's small. What does a clear path look like in a hospital or other care setting? Is it just whether, as you say, there's a path and they know about it, or whether they can see themselves in a different role? What is that for those Gen Z workers?
SPEAKER_01I think it's the opportunity to really a little bit of both, to see themselves in another role, but also to understand that they have the opportunity to define their own path. So there are so many opportunities in nursing. And when you think about Gen Z, they've just started, they're getting their feet wet, they're seeing what's going on, and they've found that, you know what, maybe I want the opportunity to learn about this. And it doesn't mean I want to leave. It means I want to learn about this or I want to become a leader or get my master's. And so they see that as if you think about anybody in any organization, everybody wants to improve their position. And so this is an opportunity to improve.
DavidSo a clear path could include lateral moves as long as it involves new skills, or does it always have to mean a promotion?
SPEAKER_01No, it doesn't always have to be a promotion. So when you think about someone who is a bedside nurse and they've done it for a long time, maybe they could get the opportunity to move to Step Down or ER and develop a whole nother set of skills. And it might not even mean they want to leave the bedside. They may come back and be stronger, be a better nurse because they learn these other skills.
Closing The Trust And Awareness Gap
DavidThat's interesting. But a path only works if employees believe their employer will help them follow it. And so sometimes that creates a what we'll call a trust gap, right? Only 26% of employees in the survey say they have a great deal of trust that their employer will support their long-term career growth. Why is that such a low number?
SPEAKER_01I think part of it is awareness. It's that communication and understanding that they need to ask the question of what's available, because there are opportunities at many organizations, but they just don't know about them. And so because they don't feel like they're invested, the organization is invested in them. It's not that when we say Gen Z want education, what they really want is to know their organization is invested in their future. And if they don't feel that and they don't see it and have access to it, they're not going to trust that the organization is there for them.
DavidThat's interesting. It's like George Bernard Schraw said, the single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it's taken place. Managers oftentimes, I think, take for granted that employees know all about this stuff. And the question then becomes, what concrete actions can a manager take, let's say in the next four weeks, wherever they are, to make a promise about growth believable?
SPEAKER_01I think that it hopefully the managers, because the benefits are managed out of HR, the managers need to explore what can we offer? What do we offer? And how do we get that information out there? Is it posters? Is it an email? Is it part of a newsletter? Making sure that their direct reports, their staff understand we are here for you. We want you to grow with us, not out of us, right? And this is what we'll help you do.
DavidThere was some evidence in the survey that employers, or at least some employers, recognize this problem themselves. Nearly half of the employers cite too little advancement development. Education is the main reason employees leave. If they know this, what keeps them from acting? What are the barriers?
SPEAKER_01I think budget is an issue. It's always an issue. I think it's an issue in every company. But I think it's prioritizing your investment. They have a pot of money, and what are they doing with it? Can a pot be set aside or trickle in to that kind of benefit? And so I would say that might be the number one issue. And the second one is not understanding what their employees want. The employees are actually saying this is what we want. The employers aren't hearing them. So the employees need to advocate for their needs.
DavidOn the company side, where does the responsibility sit with HR, with the direct supervisor, with leadership, or do all of the above?
SPEAKER_01I would say it's all of the above. I don't think HR makes the decisions about what benefits are going to be offered, but they're the ones who implement the programs. And so they have a responsibility for letting people know what's available. But even nurses who have moved into leadership positions are still looking for the opportunity to improve their situation, maybe move into a higher level of leadership, or maybe leadership in a different form. And so making sure that as a leader, you let all from the CNO down, you let everybody know this is what's available, and you encourage them to take advantage of.
Education Benefits That Don't Sit Idle
DavidYou've mentioned this a couple of times, but that kind of brings us around to education as a practical retention tool. 75% of workers in the survey said they're interested in continuing education, and 81% would consider an employer-sponsored education benefits program. What sorts of learning do workers actually need?
SPEAKER_01There's really, I would say three types of learning. Number one, there's the continual learning as things change at the bedside, different kinds of care modalities, treatment modalities, they always need to keep up on those. So there's their continuing education responsibility. Then there is training, cross-training. So if you want to, like I said before, go to surgery or go to ER and you haven't, so there's that kind of training. But then there's also higher education training. Either getting that credential, getting credentialed in your area or getting that master's degree, becoming an NP, getting a different role at your organization where you can contribute at a different level.
DavidThe question, I guess, then becomes what you alluded to earlier, whether the programs are reaching the people or the people are aware of them. Because among employers that offer workforce education, in the survey, 89% said that it improves retention and career mobility, yet only 48% have a comprehensive program. What separates a meaningful program from a tuition benefit that sits on a shelf?
SPEAKER_01I'm not sure I exactly understand your question. A meaningful program is one that supports career pathways, so offers opportunities to actually talk to you about what you might want to do next and then finds ways to support it tuition reimbursement, tuition assistance, whatever that would be. The ones that sit on a shelf, if they have them and they're sitting on a shelf, shame on them. Because they're not letting people know that they're available. None of these sit should ever sit on a shelf.
DavidBut if 89% say that they know that this is an important thing for employees, and only 48% have a comprehensive program, what explains that delta? Is it budget? Is it time? Is it the ability to get the word out to people? Why that big a delta?
SPEAKER_01I think there are several things, but one is definitely communication. But if they don't have the program, it comes back to priorities. What are you going to prioritize? And if you know that offering this program is going to keep the staff that you have who have organizational loyalty, who have clinical expertise, and you look at the cost of turnover, when you have that revolving door and they're leaving to get a better benefit somewhere else, you're well served to offer them an opportunity to move along their career.
Retention Strategy Amid Nursing Shortages
DavidAnd you're on the other side of the world reading the notes from my questions because that's my next question. Retention is a huge problem and a huge opportunity at the same time. The abstract shows that a projected shortage of nearly 500,000 critical healthcare workers by 2038 and an aging nursing workforce, except for all of your grandchildren. How should leaders think about keeping current staff while replenishing the pipeline?
SPEAKER_01There are some opportunities, and we didn't look at this in the survey, but there are ways when you have nurses that are getting older aging out to keep them engaged in ways that aren't as difficult. But when we think about the number of nurses that are leaving, we are aging out. I think the average age is over 40. And when my son was in the hospital, his nurse came in, she was 75 years old. And she said, I do this because if I don't do it, who's going to do it? And so finding ways to keep the staff we have is so important, if for no other reason for their clinical skills.
DavidWhere can education help current workers move into hard-to-fill roles without taking them away from patient care?
SPEAKER_01I think that comes with flexibility. Two things that the millennials are interested in. One is the time commitment and getting that education, and then the cost. So when you look at time commitment, there are flexible programs out there. I know Capella has one. I know other organizations have one that really addresses that time commitment and lets you do your work in your own time. So that's one benefit that's really going to help nurses be able to really commit to that growth that they want so much.
DavidKind
AI In Care Without Losing Humanity
Davidof changing topic a little bit here. In the survey, only 48% of surveyed workers felt comfortable using AI in their current role, and 45% trust AI to deliver meaningful benefits to patients. What's behind that caution?
SPEAKER_01Is it just a I think there's that human touch of nursing, that being at the bedside, there's that holding that hand, having that conversation? You're not going to get that from artificial intelligence. And so understanding how it augments what you're doing, of course, that's important. But really remaining true to your role, remaining true to why you went in this profession, AI doesn't threaten that.
DavidSo where can AI ease administrative work and free up staff and personnel to spend more time with patients?
SPEAKER_01Is that a There are some AI things that nurses are using now? We didn't look at that in the survey, so I can't really speak to specifically, but I know things like electronic medical records releases or reduces administrative burden.
DavidWe've been talking about electronic medical records for ever, it seems. And someday maybe it will happen, but that day is definitely not today. We're still fractured in that system, and there's loads of different priorities. And doctors and individual practices or small practices are going, okay, that's great. I want to do that. Who's going to pay for it? We'll get there eventually, just because the world's going to change around them and they're going to have to change.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell They'll have to change. But I do have a recommendation. There's a book called The Checklist Manifesto. If you haven't read it, or if anybody listening to this hasn't read it, I really suggest you do because it's about healthcare. And there's a lot of good information in there that I think relates to things like artificial intelligence and practice.
DavidAnd we'll put a link to that in the show notes so if somebody wants to find the book easily, they can. As we close out here, let's talk about the year ahead. Employer agreement that AI skills are critical fell from 89% in 2025 to 79% in 2026. What do you make of that change?
SPEAKER_01At first it was like, woohoo, this is coming and it's going to save us all time and it's going to do these tasks. But then the realization that you really need that person at the bedside to have eyes on the patient after they need turned and so on. Are there side rails up? A robot's not going to do that. And so I think it's also recognition on the administrator's part that there are things that can augment the care that we give, but they're not going to replace what we do.
DavidIf
Measuring Progress And Investing Wisely
Davidthe healthcare leader could make just one workforce investment this year, where would where should they start?
SPEAKER_01When you look at the survey, you can see clearly what people want is that opportunity to advance their career. So if they were going to make a monetary investment, it would be on looking at their benefits, knowing what their employees want and offering that. And I think the onus is a little bit on employees too, to find out what do they offer and then take advantage of it.
DavidSo what first step would let them learn whether that investment is improving the experience of the frontline workers? They just look at retention, or is there some other method or mode that they could use to determine that?
SPEAKER_01They also do employee satisfaction surveys. So that would certainly be one, but certainly retention would be one that would be something to pay close attention to.
DavidAdele, thanks for joining us and for helping us understand what all these findings mean for the healthcare workforce. We appreciate your being here.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate the opportunity. Thank you so much.
AnnouncerThe Shift Shapers Podcast is a production of Shift Shaper strategies and may not be reproduced or quoted in whole or in part without our express written permission. Copyright 2020, all rights reserved.